Pages

Sunday, January 26, 2014

Rectification of Names II: Let’s Call a Putsch a Putsch



As part of China Matters’ campaign to rectify names, most recently marked by the classification of current Japanese foreign policy as “Japan’s Military Restoration” I hereby decree that events in Egypt, Thailand, and the Ukraine are not revolutions—they are putsches.

A revolution, as its name implies, involves the overturn of an existing system of rule, usually authoritarian, in favor of a newly constituted system of rule, usually more democratic.

A putsch, on the other hand, involves a vociferous group using street action to overturn an elected government it finds disagreeable. 

Egypt 2013 was a putsch against an elected government by a critical mass of people in the streets and barracks who didn’t want the inconvenience of waiting a year or two for their crack at power through the ballot.

This ugly state of affairs has caused a certain amount of brainhurt for people infatuated with the vision of heroic, democracy-loving, and reliably liberal masses overthrowing authoritarian regimes.  

Juan Cole is trying to sell the overthrow of the Morsi presidency in Egypt as a “revocouption”, shoehorning a certain measure of legitimacy into the military’s coup by declaring it a continuation of the original revolution thanks to the street demonstrations against Morsi and the writing of a new constitution (and thereby writing the MB’s role in the overthrow of Mubarak out of the revolutionary official history).  No sale, oh mighty promoter of the Libyan intervention, which I suppose can rebranded as the “fuckupalotaboomboom” with that nation’s descent into chaos.

Currently, the popular mandate for the putsch against Morsi leans upon the rather slender reed that about 5% more Egyptians voted in the 2014 constitutional referendum boycotted by the MB (which passed by a Saddam Hussein-worthy 98.1%) than voted in the 2012 referendum boycotted by the anti-MBs.

A similar situation obtains in the Ukraine, where the opposition has decided a putsch is preferable to waiting for another election, especially when the West is unapologetically pitching in on behalf of the anti-government forces.  The bias of Europe and the United States for advancing their geostrategic interests at the expense of even paying lip service to the electoral process would be almost comical, but for the fact that some unsavory neo-nationalist outfits are being used as shock troops in order to soften up the shaken Ukrainian government.  It will be interesting to see how far observers go in oohing and aahing over apocalyptic cityscapes and Molotov-cocktail tossing/mace-wielding “activists” going up against The Man, as Belle Waring did in a cringe-worthy post (subsequently caveated) at Crooked Timber, if there is a prospect that such scenes might be re-enacted in their countries. 

As for Thailand, the Yellow Shirts specifically want to a) bring down the government b) foreclose the possibility of a new election they would almost certainly lose and c) convince the army to intervene on their side.  Doesn’t get more putschy than that.

When I went to school in an admittedly naΓ―ve and optimistic period of history, I was taught that respect for the electoral process by both winners and losers was paramount, because if the process was not respected then the country would just go to hell in a handbasket, just as is occurring in Egypt, Ukraine, and Thailand (and, for that matter, the United States in 1860).

Although I considered corrupt the entire process of the 2000 presidential recount, from the obvious finagling of the Florida Secretary of State to Supreme Court’s Bush v. Gore decision, once the Supreme Court had spoken I considered the case closed and I’m glad that Al Gore didn’t exhort me to take to the streets with my construction helmet, rebar club, and bottle of gasoline mixed with dish detergent  to overturn the outcome (though understandably the millions of people victimized by Bush’s reign of error, starting with the citizens of Iraq, might feel differently).  A few years later, the Democrats got their president, he got a chance to f*ck things up in his own special way, and agitation for an anti-government putsch still seems to be something of a fringe obsession inside the United States.

Overseas, it’s a different story.  The current trio of putsches has not elicited a lot of impassioned “gotta respect the electoral process” harrumphing from the US government or punditocracy.  In Ukraine, the US avidity for anti-government mischief is palpable; in Egypt, we don’t want to tick off the army and endanger the Egyptian pillar of Israel’s security arrangement; and in Thailand I don’t know what; maybe we’re just interested in staying on the Army’s good side over there.

At the bottom of it all, I suppose, is the idea that it doesn’t matter if it’s a color revolution or a putsch; local political unrest is just another potential tool for advancing and protecting US interests.  But it also gives some ammunition to the PRC government in arguing that the US is not interested in democracy (I might point out that the US is a republic, not a democracy, a distinction that 200 years of protection of wealth and property rights and de jure and de facto limits on popular sovereignty has shown to be non-trivial—relax, Tom Perkins!) or even elections; it’s just interested in getting its way.






49 comments:

  1. Hire escort service in Mumbai now! 9967584737 Great variety of independent call girls in Mumbai, visit our agency to find cheap rates and best Mumbai escorts service.

    Gurgaon Escorts %%%%%%
    mahim escorts %%%%%%
    malad escorts %%%%%%
    oshiwara escorts %%%%%%
    panvel escorts %%%%%%
    parel escorts %%%%%%
    versova escorts %%%%%%
    vashi escorts %%%%%%
    call girls in mumbai %%%%%%
    escorts in mumbai %%%%%%

    ReplyDelete
  2. Choudhary Packers and Movers in Jabalpur are on a rapid rise over the past few years. The modern social trend shows that a significant portion of the population is always travelling from one place to the other to meet up business or job demands.
    packers and movers in jabalpur
    packers and movers jabalpur
    packers and movers rewa
    packers and movers in rewa
    packers and movers in satna
    packers and movers satna
    packers and movers katni
    packers and movers in katni
    packers and movers chhindwara
    packers and movers in chhindwara

    ReplyDelete
  3. Choudhary Packers and Movers in Jabalpur are on a rapid rise over the past few years. The modern social trend shows that a significant portion of the population is always travelling from one place to the other to meet up business or job demands.
    packers and movers in jabalpur
    packers and movers jabalpur
    packers and movers rewa
    packers and movers in rewa
    packers and movers in satna
    packers and movers satna
    packers and movers katni
    packers and movers in katni
    packers and movers chhindwara
    packers and movers in chhindwara

    ReplyDelete
  4. Delhi Escorts Service available for bookings 9711199171 , Fulfill your sexual dream with Independent Call Girls Delhi, You can Hire Models vila Call Girls in Delhi for hotels and beaches. Fulfill your wish and find Independent Call Girls in Delhi.

    khyalla phase escorts $$$
    indirapuram escorts $$$
    indraprastha escorts $$$
    shalimar bagh escorts $$$
    adarsh nagar escorts $$$
    ajmeri gate escorts $$$
    alaknanda escorts $$$

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous4:20 AM


    We are welcoming to you neighborly top class escort service in Connaught Place. visit my website:-

    connaught place Escorts
    dwarka Escorts
    aerocity escortss
    janakpuri escorts
    vasant vihar
    vasant kunj Escorts
    mahipalpur Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  6. Mumbai Escorts Love is offering such Hot Mumbai Call Girls at affordable rates. Book +91 9920725232 to rent Escorts in Mumbai Services for sexual fun.

    Andheri East Escirts Service $$$$
    Andheri West Escirts Service $$$$
    Nariman Point Call Girls Service $$$$
    Nerul call Girls Service $$$$
    Mumbai Airport Call Girls Service$$$$

    ReplyDelete
  7. janakPuri escorts ###

    Welcome to VIP Delhi Escorts, the escort agency with the excellent skills of love making. Our Call Girls service in Delhi can make anyone happy because we are available 24/7. You can feel free to call us: 9873940964 anytime.

    ghaziabad escorts ###
    faridabad escorts ###
    noida escorts ###
    greater kailash escorts ###
    call girls in delhi ###
    independent delhi escorts ###

    ReplyDelete

  8. Hellow Everyone. Attention please. neha is the most beautiful girl of lajpat nagar. she is singal and waiting for you. Contact us on :-9899900591 for fully sexual satisfaction. visit my website:-
    Chanakyapuri Escorts

    Paschim Vihar Escorts

    Punjabi Bagh Escorts

    Rohini Escorts

    East of Kailash Escorts

    Raipur Escorts

    Udaipur Escorts

    Jodhpur Escorts

    Greater Noida Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous12:06 AM

    Noida escort service,For Unlimited Fun With our Russian girls, Air Hostess,HiTech Co. Girls/Women,House Wife we are provide top service

    rajiv chowk escorts

    janakpuri escorts

    barakhamba road escorts

    noida escort service

    call girls in noida

    ReplyDelete
  10. Anonymous6:22 AM

    Today, whenever an Indian man plans to hire noida escorts, ours is the first name the flashes upon his mind. We are the biggest and the most highly sought-after providers.

    azadpur escorts ***
    badarpur escorts ***
    bali nagar escorts ***
    bawana escorts ***
    bela road escorts ***
    bhajanpura escorts ***
    bhogal escorts ***
    bhorgarh escorts ***
    bijwasan escorts ***

    ReplyDelete

  11. Call Now +91-987-394-0964 Delhi Escorts offers sizzling Hot and Exotic independent escort service in Delhi. Delhi Call Girls Hub of beauty Models.

    call girls chanakyapuri ***
    call girls connaught place ***
    call girls lajpat nagar ***
    call girls munirka ***
    call girls defence colony ***
    call girls east of kailash ***
    call girls hauzkhas ***
    call girls pitampura ***
    call girls mayur vihar ***
    call girls paharganj ***

    ReplyDelete
  12. Delhi Beauties welcomes you to a very beautiful Independent Call Girls and Escort Service. Call:9711199012, We Provide Female escorts in Delhi we are available 24/7.

    call girls palam vihar ####
    call girls paschim vihar ####
    call girls kalkaji ####
    call girls bhorgarh ####
    call girls budh vihar ####
    call girls chawri bazar ####
    call girls gautam nagar ####

    ReplyDelete

  13. Contact to young and hot call girls in noida for fully enjoyment and sexual satisfaction. you can book girls on phone .contact me @9873940964.visit my website :-
    surajkund call girls

    mukherjee nagar call girls

    khan market call girls

    ashram call girls

    munirka call girls

    ReplyDelete
  14. Plan Your Shifting with Best Movers & Packers in Ghaziabad Delhi Faridabad Gurgaon to another city Plan Your Relocation with Best Packers and Movers in Faridabad Gurgaon Delhi Ghaziabad to Vadodara Surat Mumbai Pune Goa. Nevertheless, now in case you need to move then you have the best decision i.e. Relocato Removals. We promise you that you will have an awesome illicit relationship of moving. Just call us and we will doubtlessly help you.
    Best Packers and Movers in Ghaziabad

    ReplyDelete
  15. Trucking Cube provides Transport Services, Moving Truck service, Rental Trucks service, etc at an affordable cost. Contact us if you need this kind of services.

    Cheap moving truck companies
    freight company cost
    truck rentals companies

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi.........Guys? i am riyaagarwal from noida. i am college girl n singal. i wanna friendship with cool and handsome boy, i am waiting for you. call us on :-9873940964. if you want to know about us in detail visit my website:-rohini escorts

    saket escorts

    lajpat nagar escorts

    mahipalpur escorts

    indirapuram escorts

    kaushambi escorts

    vaishali escorts

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hellow Guys? my name is payalaggarwal.i am working as a call girl. i am from delhi and singal. i am intresting to meet young and handsome boys. call me on :- 9873940964.For get more details visit my website :-vasantkunj Escorts

    vikaspuri Escorts

    indirapuram Escorts

    kaushambi Escorts

    rajnagar Escorts

    vaishali Escorts

    vasundhra Escorts

    faridabad Escorts

    ghaziabad Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hello Friends i am Beautiful hot & sexy girl. you want to sex with me. call now :- 9873777170
    Visit My Website Links : -
    safdarjung escorts ☺☺
    hauz khas escorts ☺☺
    gautam nagar escorts ☺☺
    vasant kunj escorts ☺☺
    malviya nagar escorts ☺☺
    Hello Friends i am Beautiful hot & sexy girl. you want to sex with me. call now :- 9873777170
    Visit My Website Links : -
    safdarjung escorts ☺☺
    hauz khas escorts ☺☺
    gautam nagar escorts ☺☺
    vasant kunj escorts ☺☺
    malviya nagar escorts ☺☺

    ReplyDelete
  19. We are a goal-oriented interactive Los Angeles website design company that offers heart and soul to deliver innovative web design services, Wordpress development, and digital marketing solutions across the United States and Canada.


    web design los angeles

    ReplyDelete
  20. You would never get the opportunities of making complains against the services of Faridabad Escorts .They seem to be just overwhelming their clients as and whenever they are in needs trying to ease down the level of pains and boredom in lives.visit my website:-
    πŸ‘‰ call girls janakpuri
    πŸ‘‰ call girls kapashera
    πŸ‘‰ call girls karolbagh
    πŸ‘‰ call girls lajpat nagar
    πŸ‘‰ call girls mahipalpur
    πŸ‘‰ call girls malviya nagar
    πŸ‘‰ call girls mayur vihar
    πŸ‘‰ call girls mehrauli

    ReplyDelete
  21. Faridabad Escorts service welcomes you.join us and live the magic moments of your life.contact us on :-9873940964.visit my website:-
    Pitampura escorts #
    Rohini escorts #
    Saket escorts #
    South ex escorts #
    Uttam nagar escorts #
    Vasant kunj escorts #
    Vikas puri escorts #
    Indirapuram escorts #

    ReplyDelete
  22. Get professional Escort girls in Rohini 09999965857 from here at cheap rates. Enjoy your today night with Rohini escorts service girl in hotel room or at your.

    gurgaon escorts service ###
    greater noida escorts service ###
    noida extension escorts service ###
    noida escorts service ###
    ghaziabad escorts service ###
    gaur city escorts service ###


    ReplyDelete
  23. Anonymous4:18 AM

    Call Zara Chaudhry for hot Chennai Escorts.for Girlfriend Experience in Chennai are available Independent Chennai Escorts is offering Cheap Independent women at affordable rates.to rent VIP Call Girls in Chennai 5 Star Hotels.

    chennai escorts ###
    chennai escorts ###
    chennai escorts ###
    chennai escorts ###
    chennai escorts ###
    chennai escorts ###
    chennai escorts ###
    chennai escorts ###

    ReplyDelete
  24. Compare and hire professionals for packers and movers, interior designing, pest control, storage & warehousing, home shifting, household storage in Bangalore, Kolkata, Delhi NCR, Mumbai, Pune & other cities in India.


    Moving and Storage
    Car Transportation
    Storage and Warehousing
    Corporate relocation
    Interior Design

    ReplyDelete
  25. I read a few articles on this webpage page and I think your Mumbai Escorts blog is to an exceptional degree boggling and has brilliant information. Much thankfulness to you for your sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  26. The Bangalore Escorts always fulfill the sensual love of their customers. The customers never feel boring when they avail the service of Bangalore escorts.you should be very careful while you will choose your dream escort professionals. You should go through the profile. visit my website:-
    commercial street call girls
    cooke town call girls
    cunningham road call girls
    devanahalli call girls
    domlur call girls
    electronic city call girls
    hbr layout call girls
    hebbal call girls
    hmt layout call girls

    ReplyDelete

  27. The Independent Escorts Ahmedabad helps their customers by different ways. If any customer requires the help of Ahmedabad escort to find out any affordable and ideal hotel for residing in Ahmedabad then these escort workers will definitely help them. visit my website:-
    gota escorts ###
    prahlad nagar escorts ###
    sg highway escorts ###
    mani nagar escorts ###
    thaltej escorts ###
    hebatpur escorts ###
    sabarmati escorts ###
    navrangpura escorts ###
    satellite escorts ###

    ReplyDelete
  28. Anonymous12:43 AM


    Hyderabad Escorts Service give you 100% satisfaction and safe, Our ... 24*7 Are you Seeking for Hyderabad Call Girls or Fantastic College Call Girls. book at low prize.

    hyderabad escorts ###
    hyderabad escorts ###
    hyderabad escorts ###
    hyderabad escorts ###

    ReplyDelete
  29. Get the high class professional aerocity call girls at Aerocity location, book now for get the fun & enjoyment.
    http://www.yamnisingh.in/

    ReplyDelete
  30. WE offer VIP aerocity Escorts Girls in delhi. Best russian Call Girls in aerocity,We provide Arab Ladies, petite European Porn Star Models and busty Japanese Girls for A-Level Outcall & Incall.

    paharganj escorts **
    karol bagh escorts **
    defence colony escorts **
    rk puram escorts **
    pitampura escorts **
    punjabi bagh escorts **

    ReplyDelete
  31. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Best High class professional russian call girls in noida, book now for more beautiful and hot girl. Make your night romantic with our call girls.
    http://www.russianescortdelhi.com/

    ReplyDelete




  33. Welcome To Double Deal Escorts Original Escorts In Lahore Miss Leena 0305-3777077 Provider Lahore Call Girls Double deal Professional Call Girls .Services Best Hotels Pakistani Lahore Escorts Service Karachi Islamabad Rawalpindi call girls Hot Sex Girls VIP Escorts Lahore Luxury Call Girls In Lahore Available Lahore Escort Model Girls..

    ReplyDelete
  34. Anonymous6:06 AM

    The Independent Andheri girls is there to ensure that you enjoy your time with these ladies to the fullest. They are very passionate about this profession so they also enjoy the time with their clients. visit to more: http://anjalipathak.superweb.ws/ |

    ReplyDelete
  35. Best Pest Control Company In Dubai | Way Pest Control
    Way Pest is the number one pest control company in Dubai and its surrounding areas in UAE. Throughout our 10-plus years of experience, we have dealt with UAE’s pest infestations.

    ReplyDelete