Friday, October 05, 2007

The Mystery of the Dropped Fuel Tanks

I had vowed to give up blogging on Middle Eastern affairs.

However, an e-mail from a reader concerning the Israeli raid on a purported North-Korea-linked military facility in Syria enticed me to wander off the Asian affairs res once again.

FYI, the combat radius of an F-15 in deep strike mode is 1800km
The distance to the Syrian target is ~ 700 km.

No need for drop tanks........

Hmmm. Too interesting to pass up.

The Internet is a treasure trove for armchair commanders and aviation and weapons enthusiasts. Industrious googling yielded the following information:

During the raid, some Israeli aircraft jettisoned two external fuel tanks up by the Turkish border.

The tanks were from an F-15I fighter bomber , called the “Ra’am” or “Thunder”, itself the Israeli variant of the F-15E Strike Eagle.

In agreement with my correspondent, the Observer states the Ra’am is:

...the newest generation of Israeli long-range bomber, which has a combat range of over 2,000km when equipped with the drop tanks.

But I think the Observer (and perhaps *gasp* a loyal reader) got it wrong. Either they confused cruising range with combat range, or confused the current F15I with its previous incarnations (for instance the F15C does have a combat radius of 2000 km).

The F-15E is a completely different animal from previous F-15s, which were sleek interceptors, designed “without a pound for the ground” i.e. no air to ground armament, for those days of air-to-air combat with the parfait knights of the Soviet bloc.

The F-15E is a big, fat hog of a plane, sometimes nicknamed the Flying Tennis Court, or Rodan for its resemblance to the ungainly but murderous superpterodactyl featured in the Godzilla movies.

It’s meant to carry big bombs and missiles to blow up stuff on the ground and the people standing in it or next to it, and fight its way out if necessary.

So it’s got bigger engines and less range than previous F15s.

According to the data I dug up, the F-15E has a combat radius—the distance it can be expected to fly for a mission assuming high speed, fuel-consuming maneuvers--of 790 miles (see here and here ).


To achieve this radius, it needs its internal fuel plus external fuel.

Internal fuel capacity is 5,952 kg.

External fuel consists of two components:

Conforming fuel tanks or CFTs with a total capacity of 4500 kg. They are integral parts of the plane—one report I read said the plane isn’t really designed to fly without them—and can’t be jettisoned.

Then there’s another 5500 kg in conventional external fuel tanks—the kind that were dropped during the mission.

With a fistful of caveats, the combat radius for an F-15I without the external fuel tanks would be around 500+ miles.

Distance from the Hatzerim airbase (home of the F-15I-equipped 69th Squadron) near Beersheba to Dayr az Zawr: 420 miles.

So you might think that the conventional external fuel tanks weren’t needed for this particular mission, and the only reason to carry them was for road-testing prior to some Iran-related hanky-panky.

Maybe yes, maybe no.

If the Israelis really did bomb Dayr az Zawr, it’s unclear why they went barnstorming up to the Turkish border a hundred miles away.

But they certainly did go, and to fly that kind of mission including a flyby of the Turkish border, I think they would need the external fuel tanks.

Maybe the Turkey excursion was to test some fancy new electronic countermeasures equipment mounted on another plane, called “Suter”, to disrupt Russian air defense hardware recently supplied to Syria—and Iran, for Israel’s benefit and our own.

Aviation Week put out the story courtesy of “U.S. officials”:

A Kuwaiti newspaper wrote that "Russian experts are studying why the two state-of-the art Russian-built radar systems in Syria did not detect the Israeli jets entering Syrian territory. Iran reportedly has asked the same question, since it is buying the same systems and might have paid for the Syrian acquisitions."


We got a certain amount of military chest-thumping about how cool this new gear is, but these planes only jettison their fuel tanks if they’ve been engaged and need extra speed and mobility, which leads one to believe it couldn’t have worked too great.

As to Israeli insistence that they’ll take out Iran if we can’t get off our collective rears, I found this analysis interesting and persuasive.

It argues that the Israeli air force simply doesn’t have the horses to haul the armament needed to make a terminal dent in the hardened and dispersed Iranian facilities on a 1200-mile mission—remember, more fuel means fewer weapons carried--unless the U.S. either assists in the refueling of the Israeli planes or allows them to stage the assault U.S. from bases in Iraq.

And maybe not even then.

Bottom line:

Theoretically, the Israelis could do this, but at great risk of failure. If they decide to attack Natanz, they will have to inflict sufficient damage the first time - they probably will not be able to mount follow-on strikes at other facilities.

When all the analyses are done, there is only one military capable of the sustained widespread air operations required to eliminate Iran's nuclear weapons research program - the United States.

So it looks like the Israelis could start something—but it would be up to Uncle Sam to finish the job.

I take this as support for my thesis that a key data point for Israel from the Syria raid was the nature of the U.S. support it did—or did not—elicit, and what that would mean for Israel if it conducted a dramatic but less than conclusive raid on Natanz with the hope that the U.S. could be dragged into the campaign.

So: War with Iran—it’s up to us. Don’t know whether that’s reassuring or disturbing.

8 comments:

Seo Link Master said...

increase miles per gallon, fuel saver, increase gas mileage

Chad B. said...

I got two words for you: Aerial Refueling

Israel flies aerial tanker versions of both the Boeing 707 and Lockheed C-130. Getting to Iran is no problem, just a question of whether the US lets them, since the US currently controls Iraqi airspace.

Note also that Jordan's air force is better than it was in 1980 - the US gave them a couple dozen F-16's in the late 90's.

Tanya said...

Hmmm, that was interesting. Looks like somethings will always remain mystery.

I myself has been trying to solve the mystery of the legend that forces you to have "earn it before

having it", for a wile now. Could not understand much though.

Let me know in case you get to understand the mystery of the Old Hound and the Legend

By the way, good writing style. I'd love to read more on similar topics

Saili said...

Man, I followed that the dark truth link, and was completely in the story. Damn exciting. The latest post talks about a friend of him who's gone missing . Somewhere on his way to Leh, India. And the guy is asking for help find it. Soundss like an online game . This looks interesting. M already hooked on.

Hey, btw, nice post you have there - keep rocking - ;)

happyoutlet said...

vibram five fingers footwear
?How would you keep the other leg a healthy body, should be marketed and implemented

Monster Beats Ferrari
Azines

discount vibram five fingers
ff3The CSR is to "Keep the stuff

Beats by dr dre
Dre and Jimmy resolved Lovins Chairman Interscope, they can perfectly duplicate the sound, which can be produced in the facility

S

Gucci Abbey Bags

lee said...

iabaratti, like the majority of men about the excursion, driven for you to San Felipe with regards to 230 mile after mile (354 km's) to the south with the national boundaries city of Tijuana all over Nike Air Max through HillcrestIn stated within a quick record e-mailed towards the Linked MediaDALVAY BY-THE-SEA, Prince Edward Area (AP) Prince Bill enjoyed showing his or her army heli-copter instruction with his first-ever h2o landing Saturday to the Air Max 2011 pleasure involving nervous throngs in Canada, exactly where he / she with his fantastic better half, Kate, have been getting their first recognized international excursion considering that the weddingYour woman spoke to him quickly by simply Ed Hardy Shop cellular phone and also claimed he or she pointed out some thing about a electrical surpriseYour vessel capsized a lot less than 3 mls (Three kms) coming from shore, even so the fast extensive it is Discount Burberry Cheap look for 58 a long way (One hundred kilometers) further into your west coast of florida after Saturday after searching the spot by helicopter and airline in addition to obtaining absolutely nothing, Pineda explained Benjamin Pineda Ed Hardy Shop Gomez explained he simply no identify or even specifics of the guy who past awayExxon Mobil has projected of which approximately Just one,000 casks, or maybe 49,000 gallons, connected with crude oil poured Exclusive previous night Nike Air Jordan Cheap your move in the destroyed pipe ended up being quit But temperatures reached the particular mid-90s Wednesday, inducing the melt connected with off-road snow in order to speed up"They shed almost everything,Inch she said, such as air jordan clearance car keys

sam danos said...

phone number lookup

cheapuggs said...

Discount UGGs Yes, Dynasty passed away, the public should feel comfort to him.

uggs sale cheap In the end what happened, the family could not even have been laid off drivers servant? lj43vuh

uggs boot sale Yinbai great music, convulsed with laughter.

cheap uggs sale The original incident had Miaohong home tuition, Shen Wu feel unwell on the outside, hurry home to rest, a door has been lying on the ground, call an ambulance to come from the Miao Hong, and then his wife and Yin Bai Shen notice.

www.discountuggssale.us After a child, he did not see Miaohong eat the ice cream, they get to the front, three arrested two sets of clear the dishes, he suddenly remembered Miaohong not Yinbai like, but obviously two people, this behavior is no doubt that he is too pro-anonymous , suddenly big embarrassment for the cover, Jizhao waiter checkout.