Wednesday, December 16, 2009

Bloody Kashmir, Bloody India, and the Bloody Deal

Western media is always on the alert for China’s insults to its Uighur and Tibetan minorities. Certainly, China’s occupation of Tibet since 1950 has been a brutal, bloody botch that killed upwards of half a million Tibetans during the rebellion in the 1950s and during the Cultural Revolution. Despite China’s determined efforts to fulfill its enlightened despot role and reduce the body count in recent decades, Tibet’s hostility to Han control is intense, justified, and seemingly terminal.

But I think the well-oiled Western outrage machine gives a free ride to India, and brushes aside New Delhi’s ongoing shenanigans in Arunachal Pradesh, Sikkim, Nepal, Jammu-Kashmir, Balochistan, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, and Afghanistan as “nothing to see here” efforts by the dominant power (and vibrant democracy!) in the region to secure its sphere of influence.

Kashmir is the place where India’s democratic ideals and regional power aspirations collide with the greatest violence.

Kashmir is largely Muslim; it would have ended up in Pakistan at partition in 1947 but for the fact that its ruling Maharajah was a Hindu and something of a dingbat.

As it has clung to Kashmir for six decades, India has recapitulated Israel’s policies on the West Bank, occupying the region, ignoring U.N. resolutions calling for a plebiscite, and steadfastly resisting calls to internationalize the issue even as Kashmir’s insurgency exploded following a rigged election in 1989.

India has benefited from Western support and complacency in keeping Kashmir off the international front burner.

An EU delegation visited Kashmir in November; its statement that “Kashmir is an integral part of India” was triumphantly and extensively trumpeted in the Indian press.

The United States, as part of its pro-India tilt in Asian policy south of the Tibetan plateau, as recently as December 10 formally rejected a call by Pakistan’s president Asif Zardari to insert itself in the issue.

Kashmir is a big deal and a big problem.

Here are some numbers:

Population of India—controlled territories of Jammu, Kashmir, and Ladakh: 10,000,000

Muslims as % of population: 67%

Number of people who demonstrated in the Kashmiri capital of Srinigar in 2008 to protest the Indian government’s transfer of 100 acres of land (out of a total of 6000 square miles in the total parcel) to a Hindu religious board to construct shelters for pilgrims visiting the sacred cave at Amarnath in Kashmir to worship a phallus-shaped ice stalagmite known as the Shivalingam that waxes and wanes with the seasons but is, most Hindus will indignantly tell you, not a phallic symbol: 500,000

Indian troops stationed in Kashmir: 700,000

Since all Americans are by now counterinsurgency experts, we note immediately that the locals to troops ratio is an eye-popping 14:1.

That’s the sign of a major security problem. In fact, that’s the sign of a major insurgency.

If we had gone into the Iraq occupation with those kinds of numbers (instead of Donald Rumsfeld’s ratio of roughly 300,000 troops per 24 million Iraqis for a ludicrous 80:1 or the industry standard of 50:1), we would probably have been able to keep a lid on things, too.

Make no mistake: the Indian occupation of Kashmir is as bloody, expensive, oppressive, and unpopular as the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories or, for that matter, the Chinese occupation of Tibet.

68,000 Kashmiris have died in the conflict, which reached its height in 2001 and then waned, apparently because Pakistan lessened its support of Kashmiri militants under U.S. pressure after 9/11. (By way of contrast, the Israel-Palestinian struggle has claimed less than 10,000 lives over twenty years).

The conflict has produced a great deal of ugliness and cruelty as India has pursued in heavy-handed occupation and counterinsurgency strategy in Kashmir at odds with its image as Asia’s democratic paragon.

Tim Sullivan of the AP filed a report on atrocities in Kashmir that should have received wider notice.

According to Sullivan, human rights groups have discovered 2400 bodies in multiple graveyards of the estimated 8,000 Kashmiris who were “disappeared” by Indian security forces during the worst of the insurgency in the 1990s:


Two decades after the insurgency broke out, only a tiny fraction have been accounted for.

The bodies themselves give a few clues. According to villagers ordered by police to bury them, they are often of particular sorts: there is blood and shattered bone where they were shot, or they are burned beyond recognition. Many show signs of beatings. At one cemetery, police told villagers they would bring seven bodies for burials. They brought seven heads


If support for the insurgency has withered, the Indian soldiers are still widely detested. Perhaps nowhere more than in the villages forced to bury the dead.

Atta Mohammed knows all about the nameless dead. The 70-year-old Bimyar farmer has buried 235 of them. He knows their bruises and their bullet wounds. He knows if they were burned so badly their mothers would not recognize them.

"I took mud from their mouths and ears. I cleaned the blood from them," said Atta, a quiet man with rotting teeth and a neatly trimmed white beard. About 12 years ago, police began bringing bodies to be buried in a small empty field. They stopped only when there was no more room.

The West gives overwhelming weight to India’s democratic system, its role as a victim of Islamicist terror, its support for U.S. strategic goals in South Asia, and its value is an anti-China chesspiece in the great game of Asian policy.

And it may be justified to take the Chinese occupation of Tibet—instead of the Israeli occupation of the West Bank—as the standard of comparison for Indian misbehavior in Kashmir.

Indeed, I would expect there is a dark deal at work: the governments of the West have decided to turn the same official blind eye to India’s occupation of Kashmir as they do to China’s presence in Tibet so that both powers can contentedly brutalize their subjugated minorities without interference while fulfilling their assigned roles in the multi-polar, U.S.-directed 21st century world.

I can imagine that, in the continual cycle of wounded pride, horse-trading, and reassurance that goes on between New Delhi and Washington in the shadow of China’s strategic, economic, and fiscal importance, India insisted that, if human rights in Tibet was off the diplomatic table, human rights in Kashmir should be removed as well.

In fact, the first conspicuous retreat from the ideals of Obama’s election campaign to the realities of his presidency was the removal of Kashmir from the brief of Richard Holbrooke, who was expected to broker the rapprochement and grand anti-terrorism alliance between the civilian governments of Pakistan’s Asif Zardari and India’s Monmohan Singh.

Instead, India’s democracy was granted (im)moral parity with China’s single party dictatorship in the matter of how it could treat its occupied territories.

Meanwhile the Western media keeps the anti-Communist pot boiling by bashing China and coddling India.

But there is a bloody side to India that we are unwilling to confront.

22 comments:

Kirti said...

Dude, you need to relax

I am not sure this is the same thing. China ran its own people at Tianeneman - Are you really suggesting that this is similar?

blowback said...

Since Jammu is predominantly Hindu and Ladakh if approximately an equal mix of Shia and Buddhists, self determination would be unlikely to result in those parts of Jammu and Kashmir wanting to becoming part of a Pakistan. Futhermore, since Pakistan is occupying part of Kashmir, do you think it likely that Pakistan would give up that territory if Muslim Kashmiris voted for independence from both Pakistan and India. Oh, and let's not forget that Pakistan has settled its own nationals in Kashmiri territory, a war crime or West Pakistan's behaviour in former East Pakistan. That some in the Pakistan military still blame India for the "loss" of that colony beggars belief. So, I say a pox on all of them but Indian rule might still be better than Pakistani rule although probably worse than independence for Kashmir less Jammu and Ladakh.

Madhu Dube said...

ok...china matters...please look into your own problems...leave kashmir aside...you have no idea what you are talking about...we indians know and feel what price we have paid for them to be with us and keep them safe. The day india liberate kashmir...they will fight themselves and will further divide themselves, creating further problem for us.
Nobody have a right to talk about kashmir until n unless they themselves are not Indian or Kashmiris.
It's a china propaganda to start creating issues where there are none...so that we get busy in that and forget the main thing....rise n shine. We as India are rising n shining and now whole world is scared of us. They want to keep us pulled down by creating conflicts among us. We will rise n shine and whole world will witness this sooner than you can think.

Kirti said...

Hardly a comparison to the systematic and efficient slaughter of ethnic Muslim minorities and of course the Tibetans. Which continues today - and the reason the world notices it is because the victims are truly innocent and unable to fight back.

If really given a choice probably 90% of Taiwan would want no ownership link with the PRC.

I am sure even HK would secede if they could without violence and torture. So are you going to let them?

The Kashmir mess is much more convoluted and complex and there are many sides and views on this. Hardly as clear as Tibetan being slaughtered or forced to obey.

Force is often used by people who have no ability to get cooperation any other way. But I think there are shades of grey sometimes.

Mark said...

I must congratulate you on writing about something that all western journalists/pundits simply pretend does not exist. I will go a bit further and say that the Pakistanis will only see US as their friend if it brokers an honest peace in Kashmir Valley.
And for once in our lifetimes, US needs pakistani friendship more than they need US.

P.S. It is amusing to see INDIANS defend their 61 year old bloody occupation as simply a territorial dispute. Peter you will now experience unprecedented Indian wrath. Good luck.

denk said...

ch
**China’s occupation of Tibet since 1950 has been a brutal, bloody botch that killed upwards of half a million Tibetans during the rebellion in the 1950s and during the Cultural Revolution.**

i think tibet researchers like grunfeld etc and ex dir of Free Tibet Campaign, no less, had challenged this "genocide" assertion, so lets leave it at that.....an unsubstantiated allegation eh ?

anyway the chinese just dont get it, the day they sign up for the uncle sam fan club like bharat
http://tinyurl.com/ydtkpg2
aka the "teflon club", nuthin will sticks anymore
http://tinyurl.com/yffk2d8
hell, we all know that hmdl and kader, the head honcho of the "freedom fighters" from tibet and xinjiang, can get an audience with prez and the gents at the hill any time they wish, standing ovation and all.
but when was the last time a "terrarist" chieftan from kashmir or assam, nagaland, manipur, the naxals etc was bestowed such honour....not that i know of anyway ;-)
sigh, the chicoms just dont get it, thats their trouble.

denk said...

kirti
**I am not sure this is the same thing. China ran its own people at Tianeneman - Are you really suggesting that this is similar?**


no it isnt,
firstly as far as i am concerned, the jurists are still out on what happend in tam 1989,
http://tinyurl.com/5ahqd6
the only thing we can be sure is that its a failed cia caper.
otoh, the bloodpath in kashmir is well documented.
http://tinyurl.com/yghh3so

seondly,
while tam [just like tibet and now xinjiang] has been done to death by the anglos press, the 1984 massacre of the sikhs, the 2001 pogrom on the muslims and the 2008 atrocities against the christians in orissa are non events.

while the us [the usual suspects] imposed a international sanction against china after tam, which probably slowed china's development for at least a decade [as desired ?], the yanks invited the chief minister of nadingram "to hear about the political and development aspects of his success"......just one month after his troops mowed down about a 100 protestors with assault rifles !
http://tinyurl.com/dem373
[i'd cut the anglos some slack here, they probably didnt read about this crime either, what with the kind of media they have]

right now the anglos diplomats in china, led by us , uk, are falling over themselves to take up the cudgel for a "dissident" who is being tried for "inciting instability".
ah, the chinese are so blessed, they seem to have these anglo guardian angles hovering over them 24x7
but i cant help but wonder, where were these anglo hr enforcers in 1998 , during the pogrom on indon chinese in jakarta, u know, all it take was a call to "our kind of guy suharto" and those poor sods would be spared, no need to launch a 78 days bombings like when they did in "saving the muslims" [sic] in kosovo.

you know something, somehow i have this feeling that these anglos are such racists, they yap about every "dissident" trial in china while some pogrom are going on in next door india every other day.
do they think that indian lives are cheaper ? ;-}

Kirti said...

I guess if one has already come to a conclusion there is not much point in further discussion on this.

To dismiss Tiananmen as a CIA plot I think is pretty far fetched but since you have a source that has convinced you so why argue any more. I have talked to people who were there as students and who saw friends gunned down.

Also your source for the Kashmiri situation is a guy who is on one side of the fence and yes he makes his point from that vantage point. Why don't you look at the other possible views on this situation?

How many people do you know that have made critical comments about the Chinese government and were able to live without harassment or violence in China?

It is easy and generally not dangerous to write scathing criticisms of the Indian government, in the press and the web, and many do everyday in India.

So while your original point is provocative, it is kind of weak and does not stand up well against what most people know as true and factual about these subjects and issues.

There is clearly great progress in China but it is also clear to most that one does not criticize anything official in China with impunity. There are few if any opposing opinions to any official stand.

The fact that the Chinese government basically holds the Dalai Lama as a symbol of terrorism says more about them than it does about the Dalai Lama.

But for many of us, getting a balanced and accurate picture is not important. We are looking for info that supports our bias and perhaps this is even true for me.

Good luck with your Bloody India campaign - I hope that it does rise to surface if there is any truth in it.

Kirti said...

Here is another voice from Kashmir - I don't think your key reference represents this person.

In a major initiative to widen the access to classic and modern languages, fifty rare and greatest work of English, Persian and Sanskrit are chosen to be rendered into Gojri, the third largest spoken language of Jammu and Kashmir said Dr. Javaid Rahi a senior functionary of J&K Academy of Art, Culture and Languages in a meeting of prominent Gojri writers held here today. He said that this long-term project was initiated to bring world class and landmark works into Gojri to enrich this ancient tribal language spoken by the Gujjar tribe. He said that under this prestigious project 21 classics have already been published in Gojri language which include world famous work like Mathnavi Moulana Rumi, "Gulistan-e-Saddi” Rubiyat-e-Umar Khayam, Karwan-e-Madina , Shakespeare's Othello and King Lear, Sanskrit's Neelmat Puran , the autobiography of Mahatma Gandhi "My Experience with Truth", Shahan-e-Gujjars and others. This Project is scheduled to be completed by the end of 2011, he said. Dr. Rahi, the project head and Chief Editor of the State Academy further told that the project was aims to revitalize the art of translation among Gujjars across the Indian Sub-continent and reverse the long decline in Gojri readers' access to major works of global literature, philosophy, and history adding that another objective of this rare effort is to connect Gujjars to their roots which are spread over Central Asia Dr.Rahi told. This has become an official venture, as the Department of Gojri of State Academy of Art, Culture and Languages has engaged 20 prolific researchers to translate 50 world class works of 18 legendry writers of 3 classic and foreign languages of the globe for an early compilation of the Translation works, , Dr. Rahi said. Dr. Javaid Rahi said this project was conceived and designed to give a variety literature to lakhs of Gujjars and non-Gujjars speakers of Gojri who resides in India, Pakistan ,Afghanistan and other parts of the world. He said this is a unique project of its own kind in any Tribal Language of India especially in Gojri as this is one of the most ancient languages of India. “we are also working on the project of generation of high-quality translation tools such as dictionaries and software; translator education; information dissemination; development of scientific and technical terminology in Gojri including promotion of machine translation and machine-aided translation” Dr Rahi said. From this year we are starting a Translation journal in Gojri entitled “Sanjh” which will enrich Gojri through translations of various subjects. He said when completed the Gojri translation of all fifty world classics will be made available on net under e-literature project of Gojri which is under way.

Also you can see some kind of debate continues, imperfect as it is. http://www.indianexpress.com/news/jk-parties-slam-saghir-report-only-ruling-nc-has-no-objections/559037/1

While In China a dissident was jailed on Xmas day:
Trial in China Signals New Limits on Dissent http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/24/world/asia/24china.html?_r=1

denk said...

kirti

**I guess if one has already come to a conclusion there is not much point in further discussion on this.

To dismiss Tiananmen as a CIA plot I think is pretty far fetched but since you have a source that has convinced you so why argue any more. I have talked to people who were there as students and who saw friends gunned down. **

read my post properly, i merely say ONLY GOD KNOWS WHAT HAPPENED IN TAM 1989, i didnt make any "conclusion" based on clark's article, but like hell i am going to take the "western" version hook line n sinker.

and if u havent heard of ned, aka cia in pastor's garb...... can we say...such innocence ?
http://tinyurl.com/364ea4
http://tinyurl.com/2ca4h2




**Also your source for the Kashmiri situation is a guy who is on one side of the fence and yes he makes his point from that vantage point. Why don't you look at the other possible views on this situation?**

i dont "take side" in kashmir, hell i am not like those anglo "hr enforcers" [sic] i brought up this article
http://tinyurl.com/yghh3so
specifically to highlight the fact that unlike tibet, xinjiang ec, which have been cause celebre for the anglos, kashmir, assam etc " met with studied unconcern by the usual suspects...the anglo hr "enforcers",
which is the theme of this thread, in case u have forgotten




**How many people do you know that have made critical comments about the Chinese government and were able to live without harassment or violence in China?

It is easy and generally not dangerous to write scathing criticisms of the Indian government, in the press and the web, and many do everyday in India.**


i know all about aruna roy etc, but what has indian ngos and activits got to do with this thread, which is about the anglos' phoney "hr" campaign


while we are at it,
may be you should listen to roy on this illusion of democracy.
**The hoary institutions of Indian democracy -- the judiciary, the police, the "free" press, and, of course, elections - far from working as a system of checks and balances, quite often do the opposite. They provide each other cover to promote the larger interests of Union and progress. In the process, they generate such confusion, such a cacophony, that voices raised in warning just become part of the noise. And that only helps to enhance the image of the tolerant, lumbering, colorful, somewhat chaotic democracy. The chaos is real. But so is the consensus. **
http://tinyurl.com/ydd8vx8


**So while your original point is provocative, it is kind of weak and does not stand up well against what most people know as true and factual about these subjects and issues. **


??


**There is clearly great progress in China but it is also clear to most that one does not criticize anything official in China with impunity. There are few if any opposing opinions to any official stand. **


in case u havent noticed, the political climate in china is getting better by the day and grass root opposition that force the government to rescind a policy is getting more common these days........
its far from perfect, which is kinda an under statement ;-)
but then again, this is kinda out of topics innit ?


**The fact that the Chinese government basically holds the Dalai Lama as a symbol of terrorism says more about them than it does about the Dalai Lama.**

u mean that chinese chalabi, the ex serf king with an axe to grind and money to take ?
http://tinyurl.com/ypfgvy


**But for many of us, getting a balanced and accurate picture is not important. We are looking for info that supports our bias and perhaps this is even true for me.**

me too

**Good luck with your Bloody India campaign - I hope that it does rise to surface if there is any truth in it.**

god damn, u call this a "bloody india campaign" ...well u aint seen nothing yet.

http://tinyurl.com/ocpm8k

denk said...

is there something wrong with the software ?
my previous post was rejected by the system for a couple of dozens times !!
phew

uwanna said...

gucci replica handbags
men gucci shoes
Gucci men sneakers
Gucci men moccasins
gucci women sneakers
gucci women boots
Gucci men boots
Gucci
Gucci shop
Gucci bags
Gucci shoes
Replica GUCCI SHOES
wholesale gucci shoes
cheap Gucci handbags
Gucci ON sale
Gucci Belts
Gucci small accessories
Gucci hats & scarves
Gucci wallets
Gucci Handbags
Women Gucci shoes
Men Gucci shoes
discount gucci shoes
cheap Gucci shoes

manoj joshi said...

"New Delhi’s ongoing shenanigans in Arunachal Pradesh, Sikkim, Nepal, Jammu-Kashmir, Balochistan, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, and Afghanistan" A bit of apples and oranges here-- provinces and countries. BTW nothing of significance is happening in Arunachal, except for some Chinese incursions.
Had New Delhi been even half as bloody-minded as the Chinese, it would have carried out large-scale ethnic cleansing in Kashmir and ergo, no problem (the tactic China is attempting in Tibet, having shorn off chunks of Tibet to start with).

denk said...

f

denk said...

manoj joshi : 6:59 AM
**"New Delhi’s ongoing shenanigans in Arunachal Pradesh, Sikkim, Nepal, Jammu-Kashmir, Balochistan, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, and Afghanistan" A bit of apples and oranges here-- provinces and countries. BTW nothing of significance is happening in Arunachal, except for some Chinese incursions. **

yeah sure, like the 1962 "chinese invasion"
http://tinyurl.com/27fm9u


**Had New Delhi been even half as bloody-minded as the Chinese, it would have carried out large-scale ethnic cleansing in Kashmir**

ask the kashmiri women folks
http://tinyurl.com/7pbggl


*** and ergo, no problem (the tactic China is attempting in Tibet, having shorn off chunks of Tibet to start with)***

hell , history 101 for joshi
china during the yuan or is it the ching dynasty, took the whole god damned tibet, during an era when such was the norm mind u. unlike some democrazies which are still doing it in the 21 century [sic]
the anglos shorn off large chunks of southern tibet in 1903,
http://tinyurl.com/yzfqfbj

i understand u call it arunachal pradesh today ?
[aka the tibet that no anglos wanna talk about ]
http://tinyurl.com/mzhzed
can we say....state terrorism ?

otoh, in tibet and xinjiang, its cia sponsored terrorism against innocent bystanders, including hans, huis and tibetans.
gotta to go now, might elaborate on this later.


.

Dailey said...

It was great I've told our sales people they HAVE to attend next time. If a techie like me can walk away with ideas to go to sponsors with, they could have a field day!
learn to speak spanish

speaking spanish


diet plan

hypnosis training

hypnosis guides

janewangleilei said...

You can have a look at it.
jordan shoes
Wow.
newest jordans
jordan 7
Wonderful!
air yeezy
jordan true flight
If you like,you can contact us.
jordan 3
jordan 4
We offer different styles.
jordan 1
jordan 2
Thanks.
jordan 5
jordan ajf shoes
There are cheap shoes to choose
nike footwear
jordan flight 45
Good quality with low price.
air jordan 2010
Air Jordan 2009
Enjoy it!
jumpman
nike trainers

costa rica said...

Costa Rica Tours
Jaco Costa Rica Tours
Los Suenos Costa Rica Tours

A.J. Jacksoon said...

Locate not at home how to facilitate make a reverse phone lookup otherwise a cell phone search or still a telephone reverse phone lookup lookup lookup with the purpose of discover away who is down that guise that has been calling you this whole instance ok.

educationalbabytoys said...

Change mobile phone lookup webpages similar to this individual self-control give you each kinds of telephone search specifics so with the purpose of you be able to in the end unearth not on home their name, address, where they survive, reverse phone lookup their current age along with to a impressive extent more. So after you call for with the aim of squander a cell phone number search at the moment, barely do certain with the purpose of finish this effective tool with the intention of come across absent each kinds of turn around cell phone lookup particulars behind with the purpose of self in the present day.

peoplereverse said...

I enjoy this nice switch mobile phone search otherwise telephone search before phone number lookup spot. I know how to find out much of cell phone lookup stuff regarding reorder telephone lookup here these days while I checked absent this guide here.

reverse1011 said...

Squander this cell phone lookup place to facilitate find elsewhere cell phone lookup is down this mysterious cellular phone number you own questions on the subject matter of. Along with at present you can consume the matching mobile phone lookup with the aim of get a possess of persons answers through on behalf of you at present quickly with easily.