Sunday, January 26, 2014

Rectification of Names II: Let’s Call a Putsch a Putsch



As part of China Matters’ campaign to rectify names, most recently marked by the classification of current Japanese foreign policy as “Japan’s Military Restoration” I hereby decree that events in Egypt, Thailand, and the Ukraine are not revolutions—they are putsches.

A revolution, as its name implies, involves the overturn of an existing system of rule, usually authoritarian, in favor of a newly constituted system of rule, usually more democratic.

A putsch, on the other hand, involves a vociferous group using street action to overturn an elected government it finds disagreeable. 

Egypt 2013 was a putsch against an elected government by a critical mass of people in the streets and barracks who didn’t want the inconvenience of waiting a year or two for their crack at power through the ballot.

This ugly state of affairs has caused a certain amount of brainhurt for people infatuated with the vision of heroic, democracy-loving, and reliably liberal masses overthrowing authoritarian regimes.  

Juan Cole is trying to sell the overthrow of the Morsi presidency in Egypt as a “revocouption”, shoehorning a certain measure of legitimacy into the military’s coup by declaring it a continuation of the original revolution thanks to the street demonstrations against Morsi and the writing of a new constitution (and thereby writing the MB’s role in the overthrow of Mubarak out of the revolutionary official history).  No sale, oh mighty promoter of the Libyan intervention, which I suppose can rebranded as the “fuckupalotaboomboom” with that nation’s descent into chaos.

Currently, the popular mandate for the putsch against Morsi leans upon the rather slender reed that about 5% more Egyptians voted in the 2014 constitutional referendum boycotted by the MB (which passed by a Saddam Hussein-worthy 98.1%) than voted in the 2012 referendum boycotted by the anti-MBs.

A similar situation obtains in the Ukraine, where the opposition has decided a putsch is preferable to waiting for another election, especially when the West is unapologetically pitching in on behalf of the anti-government forces.  The bias of Europe and the United States for advancing their geostrategic interests at the expense of even paying lip service to the electoral process would be almost comical, but for the fact that some unsavory neo-nationalist outfits are being used as shock troops in order to soften up the shaken Ukrainian government.  It will be interesting to see how far observers go in oohing and aahing over apocalyptic cityscapes and Molotov-cocktail tossing/mace-wielding “activists” going up against The Man, as Belle Waring did in a cringe-worthy post (subsequently caveated) at Crooked Timber, if there is a prospect that such scenes might be re-enacted in their countries. 

As for Thailand, the Yellow Shirts specifically want to a) bring down the government b) foreclose the possibility of a new election they would almost certainly lose and c) convince the army to intervene on their side.  Doesn’t get more putschy than that.

When I went to school in an admittedly naïve and optimistic period of history, I was taught that respect for the electoral process by both winners and losers was paramount, because if the process was not respected then the country would just go to hell in a handbasket, just as is occurring in Egypt, Ukraine, and Thailand (and, for that matter, the United States in 1860).

Although I considered corrupt the entire process of the 2000 presidential recount, from the obvious finagling of the Florida Secretary of State to Supreme Court’s Bush v. Gore decision, once the Supreme Court had spoken I considered the case closed and I’m glad that Al Gore didn’t exhort me to take to the streets with my construction helmet, rebar club, and bottle of gasoline mixed with dish detergent  to overturn the outcome (though understandably the millions of people victimized by Bush’s reign of error, starting with the citizens of Iraq, might feel differently).  A few years later, the Democrats got their president, he got a chance to f*ck things up in his own special way, and agitation for an anti-government putsch still seems to be something of a fringe obsession inside the United States.

Overseas, it’s a different story.  The current trio of putsches has not elicited a lot of impassioned “gotta respect the electoral process” harrumphing from the US government or punditocracy.  In Ukraine, the US avidity for anti-government mischief is palpable; in Egypt, we don’t want to tick off the army and endanger the Egyptian pillar of Israel’s security arrangement; and in Thailand I don’t know what; maybe we’re just interested in staying on the Army’s good side over there.

At the bottom of it all, I suppose, is the idea that it doesn’t matter if it’s a color revolution or a putsch; local political unrest is just another potential tool for advancing and protecting US interests.  But it also gives some ammunition to the PRC government in arguing that the US is not interested in democracy (I might point out that the US is a republic, not a democracy, a distinction that 200 years of protection of wealth and property rights and de jure and de facto limits on popular sovereignty has shown to be non-trivial—relax, Tom Perkins!) or even elections; it’s just interested in getting its way.






20 comments:

Packers Movers Ahmedabad said...

Lovely Website, Maintain the fantastic work. Thank you so much!
Local Packers and Movers Ahmedabad list, Cheap Packers Movers Ahmedabad Charges, Affordable, Best Household Shifting Ahmedabad @ Packers and Movers Ahmedabad

Packers Movers Bangalore said...

I must be thankful for sharing your ideas.Thank you for the good writeup.its a brelient job.please visit here for more detail:
Packers And Movers Bangalore charges

Blogger said...

If you need your ex-girlfriend or ex-boyfriend to come crawling back to you on their knees (no matter why you broke up) you need to watch this video
right away...

(VIDEO) Get your ex back with TEXT messages?

Packers Movers Delhi said...

We Provide Best Packers And Mover sDelhi List for Get Free Best Quotes, Compare Charges, Save Money And Time, Household Shifting Services @
Packers and Movers Delhi

Local Packers and Movers said...

I must thank you for the efforts you have put in writing this site. I really hope to view the same high-grade blog posts by you in the future as well.
local packers and movers in Gurgaon
local packers and movers in Bangalore
local packers and movers in Delhi
local packers and movers in Pune
local packers and movers in Mumbai
local packers and movers in Noida
local packers and movers in Hyderabad

anukadiyan said...

nungambakkam escorts
omr road escorts
ecr road escorts
anna nagar escorts
boat club road escorts
anna salai escorts
mylapore escorts

Unknown said...

lokhandwala escorts #####
malad escorts #####
nerul escorts #####
wadala escorts #####
worli escorts #####
churchgate escorts #####

dipika khan said...

vikas puri escorts
tilak nagar escorts
daryaganj escorts
palam vihar escorts
paschim vihar escorts
sarojini nagar escorts
hari nagar escorts
sarai kale khan escorts
aya nagar escorts
ghitorni escorts

myangleshub said...

chanakyapuri escorts
chandni chowk escorts
charmwood village escorts
vasundhara escorts
daryaganj escorts
defence colony escorts
laxmi nagar escorts
dhaula kuan escorts

Unknown said...

vaishali escorts $$$$
faridabad escorts $$$$
ghaziabad escorts $$$$
noida escorts $$$$
karol bagh escorts $$$$

simasingh said...

Look Independent High class Delhi escorts services in 3 star Hotels with Photos.Book 9873940964 Hot Model escorts or Call Girls in Delhi. http://shanvibhardwaj.in/mahipalpur-escorts.html
Faridabad escorts
***
ghaziabad escorts
***
gurgaon escorts
***
noida escorts
***
greater noida escorts
***
Dhaula kuan Escorts
***
Rohini Escorts
***
Saket escorts
***
South Ex escorts
***

Unknown said...

Choose High Profile Call Girls in Delhi with Photos, Contact us at 9899900591, to book Top Model Escorts in Delhi. India's VIP Independent Delhi Escorts.

http://www.monarathi.in/escorts-service-vasant-kunj.html $$$$
http://www.monarathi.in/escorts-service-vasant-vihar.html $$$$
http://www.monarathi.in/escorts-service-vikaspuri.html $$$$
http://www.monarathi.in/escorts-service-crossings-republik.html $$$$
http://www.monarathi.in/escorts-service-gaur-city.html $$$$
http://www.monarathi.in/escorts-service-indirapuram.html $$$$
http://www.monarathi.in/escorts-service-raj-nagar.html $$$$
http://www.monarathi.in/escorts-service-vaishali.html $$$$
http://www.monarathi.in/escorts-service-vasundhara.html $$$$


kajalkumari said...

Hire escort service in Mumbai now! 9967584737 Great variety of independent call girls in Mumbai, visit our agency to find cheap rates and best Mumbai escorts service.

Gurgaon Escorts %%%%%%
mahim escorts %%%%%%
malad escorts %%%%%%
oshiwara escorts %%%%%%
panvel escorts %%%%%%
parel escorts %%%%%%
versova escorts %%%%%%
vashi escorts %%%%%%
call girls in mumbai %%%%%%
escorts in mumbai %%%%%%

missjoya said...

Find Independent High class Noida escorts services in 5 star Hotels with Photos.Call 09899900591 to book Hot Model escorts or Call Girls in Noida.

http://www.missjoya.com/escorts-service-vasant-vihar.html
http://www.missjoya.com/escorts-service-vikaspuri.html
http://www.missjoya.com/escorts-service-crossings-republik.html
http://www.missjoya.com/escorts-service-gaur-city.html
http://www.missjoya.com/escorts-service-indirapuram.html
http://www.missjoya.com/escorts-service-raj-nagar.html
http://www.missjoya.com/escorts-service-vaishali.html
http://www.missjoya.com/escorts-service-vasundhara.html

tanyabansal said...

Connaught Place Escorts|9711199171 | Escorts Girls at your Hotel 24/7 Available


connaught place escorts $$$$
greater kailash escorts $$$$
saket escorts $$$$
dwarka escorts $$$$
rohini escorts $$$$

Choudhary Packers and Movers said...

Choudhary Packers and Movers in Jabalpur are on a rapid rise over the past few years. The modern social trend shows that a significant portion of the population is always travelling from one place to the other to meet up business or job demands.
packers and movers in jabalpur
packers and movers jabalpur
packers and movers rewa
packers and movers in rewa
packers and movers in satna
packers and movers satna
packers and movers katni
packers and movers in katni
packers and movers chhindwara
packers and movers in chhindwara

Choudhary Packers and Movers said...

Choudhary Packers and Movers in Jabalpur are on a rapid rise over the past few years. The modern social trend shows that a significant portion of the population is always travelling from one place to the other to meet up business or job demands.
packers and movers in jabalpur
packers and movers jabalpur
packers and movers rewa
packers and movers in rewa
packers and movers in satna
packers and movers satna
packers and movers katni
packers and movers in katni
packers and movers chhindwara
packers and movers in chhindwara

bookyourgf said...

mumbai escorts###
mumbai escorts###
mumbai escorts###
andheri escorts###

ritikangt4u said...

Saket Call Girls | 9999965857 | Book Escorts in Saket at Hotels

saket escorts $$$$$$
mahipalpur escorts $$$$$$
nagar escorts $$$$$$
karol bagh escorts $$$$$$
dwarka escorts $$$$$$

modelsvila said...

Delhi Escorts Service available for bookings 9711199171 , Fulfill your sexual dream with Independent Call Girls Delhi, You can Hire Models vila Call Girls in Delhi for hotels and beaches. Fulfill your wish and find Independent Call Girls in Delhi.

khyalla phase escorts $$$
indirapuram escorts $$$
indraprastha escorts $$$
shalimar bagh escorts $$$
adarsh nagar escorts $$$
ajmeri gate escorts $$$
alaknanda escorts $$$