Saturday, June 06, 2015

Mdme. Tsai Goes to Washington

Mdme. Tsai Ing-wen, the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) candidate for president in the 2016 Taiwan elections, came to Washington and appeared at the Center for Strategic and International Studies a.k.a. Pivot Central to make some remarks, chat with Kurt Campbell (proud pivot pappy), and do some Q&A moderated by the indefatigable pivot sherpa Bonnie Glaser (more on that later).

Tsai gave a good account of herself in her prepared remarks: competent, appealing, moderate, etc.  She also provided a look at what a DPP wanted to do, wouldn’t do—and might be unable to do—if it gained control of the presidency, a pretty good bet given the comatose nature of the KMT’s presidential campaign.

For US audiences, perhaps the key statement was her reaffirmation of “the status quo” a.k.a. “no Taiwan independence” (go to the 17 minute mark).

Subsequently, Campbell did ask an interesting question about the cohesion of Taiwan society given its significant divisions, a sign to me that US policymakers are interested in the possibility that gridlock in Taiwan political institutions will lead to escalating “Sunflower” style street action—or perhaps a DPP gambit to piggyback on student unrest and declare that the unambiguous will of the Taiwan people expressed in mass demonstration compels an independence referendum pronto, sorry about that--and a messy opposing reaction.  Tsai responded with the generic “democratic dialogue” kumbaya optimism which, I should say, I don’t quite share.

Campbell elicited Tsai’s statement on the South China Sea issue, very much CSIS’s obsession de jour.  Tsai obligingly ticked off the talking points: peaceful, international law, UN conventions, & “as you said, freedom of navigation”.

Getting East Asian democracies to nut up and back the US SCS play is, post Shangri La, a diplomatic priority.  On June 4, Danny Russel openly called on the Republic of Korea to support the US position, apparently as part of the public frontloading of expectations for ally fealty that has become an inseparable element of pivot promotion.

Per Yonhap:

"The fact that, like the United States, the Republic of Korea is not a claimant, in my view, gives Seoul all the more reason to speak out because it is speaking not in self-interest, but speaking in support of universal principles and the rule of law," [Russel] said.

It was the first time that a senior American official has publicly asked South Korea to play a role in the territorial dispute. The remark came ahead of a visit to Washington by South Korean President Park Geun-hye later this month.

Parenthetically, I find the look for “disinterested” supporters interesting.  It is nice to get everybody to make approving noises in favor of nice things that they have no “interest” in expending blood & treasure to defend while the dominant regional power has made it clear it regards the same issue as an existential “core interest”.

Although I serially excoriate the media for falling for the “freedom of navigation in the South China Sea” canard (since the term has zero significance in terms of economic security or unhindered commercial passage that everybody is supposedly caring about), “military freedom of navigation” does have a genuine attraction to militaries that want to operate in the South China Sea. (I will cover the history of military freedom of navigation in the SCS in a subsequent post.  Consider yourself warned!)

Taiwan has its own claim in the South China Sea, indeed the largest island claim (Itu Aba), which has the largest airfield in the Spratlys (for now), and its own fresh water.  The ROC occasionally sends a submarine to Itu Aba, so it has an interest in military FoN in the SCS.

In fact, Itu Aba is in the throes of a $100 million construction project, something that Campbell obligingly forebore to mention despite the US demand that “everybody” cease island reclamation, and which Tsai naturally didn’t bring up.  The ROC even had to hire a PRC ship to haul some caissons down to Itu Aba for the construction ! The port construction is supposed to be completed in a few months and then Taiwan will be able to dock vessels, military & otherwise, there as well, and further inject itself into the SCS mix. 

An interesting element of the Philippine UNCLOS arbitration case against the PRC is that if the Philippines wins, it will also weaken Itu Aba’s presumptive claim to a 200 mile EEZ (an impassioned legal eagle in the Philippines heatedly accused a Philippine judge of treason for neglecting, perhaps for sound reasons of diplomatic calculation, to attack the Taiwan claim in the arbitration filing).  

The DPP, as befits its Taiwan indigene roots, is relatively blase about Taiwan’s island claims (Kinmen, Matsu, Tiaoyutai, and, I would guess, Itu Aba), which it regards as excess baggage Chiang Kai-shek carried to Taiwan in 1949.  So if the DPP wins, it will probably be relatively unconcerned if Itu Aba is collateral damage in the Philippine assault on the Nine-Dash-Line.  Another matter for the KMT, of course, and I wonder if the KMT will try to play the “holy ground of the motherland” card in the election.

Mdme. Tsai’s Q&A didn’t go so smoothly.  She had to field a question on the “1992 consensus”, a term the DPP detests, from a mainland journo.

The “1992 consensus” was basically an intentional and necessary muddling of the One China issue during meetings by the (KMT-controlled) Taiwan administration and the PRC in Hong Kong that enabled the development of cross-strait ties.  As befits its Taiwan independence inclinations, the DPP scorns the idea that any successor government should consider itself bound to uphold that mush-mouthed whatever it is (there was no joint declaration; heck, there weren’t even parallel unilateral statements; something was stated verbally, sometime, somewhere: "On November 3 [1992], a responsible person of the Communist Chinese ARATS said that it is willing to “respect and accept” SEF’s proposal that each side “verbally states” its respective principles on “one China.").

The DPP would apparently like to consign the One China assumption of the 1992 consensus to the dustbin of history as a steppingstone toward independence, something that becomes politically easier with every passing year as more people identify themselves as “Taiwanese” and “Chinese” identifiers become more of an eccentric niche group.

However, p*ssing off the dominant regional power & biggest trading partner ($29 billion of a $140 billion total pie) is not the most obvious path to security, prosperity, & overall happiness. 

Therefore, Tsai was quite energetic in her remarks about the unsatisfactory results of the current mainland-centric Taiwan economic model, the undesirability of further interdependence, and the need to “diversify” the Taiwan economy & shift it to “innovation” instead of manufacturing, and presumably toward the United States & Japan and away from the mainland.  She also talked about Taiwan businessmen having to learn to handle failure, perhaps a backhanded warning that the mainland-manufacturing-linked sector should brace itself for some creative destruction if/when the DPP tries to implement its diversification strategy.  Good luck with that.  

Obviously the DPP is not quite ready to talk about unambiguously dumping the 1992 consensus and with it the economic relationship with the PRC.

So for the mainland, it’s red line time and “do you affirm the 1992 consensus” has become a tactic to put the DPP on the spot and force it either to alienate the middle-of-the-road segment of the electorate (and the US) with a prematurely provocative stance or, well, revel in the spectacle of its own weakness and hypocrisy in the eyes of its base.

So Mdme. Tsai threw some serious shade on the questioner, replying coolly that she had covered that issue in her remarks.  Since she hadn’t really addressed the issue, this drew a chuckle from the audience. 

But the next two questions were on the same topic & Tsai had to repeat her “already covered this” line more and more stiffly and by the end nobody was laughing.

And the last guy also asked some PRC-friendly question about Tsai’s plans to increase Taiwan military spending.

By my count, Tsai got one softball question, and four awkward questions from PRC journos and pundits who had apparently salted the room.

Unless Bonnie Glaser intentionally called on four pro-PRC questioners to put Tsai on her mettle, which I kinda doubt, she’s going to have to hit the books and figure out the names and faces of the friendlies and the not-so-friendlies before her next hosting gig. 

My personal opinion: the PRC should be relieved, not dismayed if Tsai becomes president.  

If the KMT stays in power, activists will feed the narrative that rad street activism is needed to save Taiwan from getting sold out, the DPP will endorse and exploit the demonstrations as a matter of sound political calculation, and the ineluctable polarization of Taiwan (and the increasing marginalization of pro-mainland opinion) will accelerate.  

If Tsai is in power, on the other hand, she’ll have her hands full pushing her agenda while wrestling with the demands of the younger activists and coping with KMT obstructionism—and distracted from the vital task of trying to pull the island’s economy out of the mainland’s enormous gravitational field.


denk said...

*The fact that, like the United States, the Republic of Korea is not a claimant, in my view, gives Seoul all the more reason to speak out because it is speaking not in self-interest, but speaking in support of universal principles and the rule of law*

at times like this, i always wonder if the yanks suffer from some kind of embarrassment deficit syndrom ?

denk said...


Don Bacon said...

If Taiwan to ever get serious about independence, it would first have to give up the "Republic of China" charade it goes under, purporting jurisdiction over not only "mainland China" but also Mongolia, which are "administered" by others.

Don Bacon said...

...which, I just noticed, is another way of stating what you said: "Obviously the DPP is not quite ready to talk about unambiguously dumping the 1992 consensus ..." [one China, including Taiwan]

Xinxi said...

The opposition can't even build an industrial base for the South's semi-capital Kaohsiung. Apart from a hollow construction boom, there is hardly any noteworthy business sector in my favorite Asian city. And even formerly deep-green neighborhoods rebel against more (Mainland) tourism.
By the way: The next president will have to massively increase taxes to finance the crashing universal health care & new long-term care insurances. Benefits have already been cut sharply.
In ten years, Taiwan could become part of China because the middle-class is bled dry, the (KMT background) military families won't be motivated to fight for perceived "Hoklo First" folks, and rich clans relocating to the US or Canada.

Julie Bolton said...

Thank you for sharing. Hm... a female President will be better or worse for the world peace. Seeing what China does now in East Sea, I don't expect anything. Every woman is not easy.
super smash flash | play armor games | free games | math game | cool math | cool maths games | primary games | happy wheels | lupus facts

Juegos Juegos said...

Dank u dat we hier mogen verblijven, dank u voor het eten, dank u voor het redden van onze kinderen. Dat is wat we met deze actie willen zeggen, zei Khaldoun Al Barmawee in Emmen.
gry frozen gry 2016 online jogos 2016 mafa minions
dank je wel, dit zijn goede antwoorden, maar het zijn antwoorden op een andere vraag.
papa louie mafa papa louie fynsy gogy
Daarbovenop is er de psychologische weerstand tegen doedelen -- dank je wel, Freud.

Juegos Juegos said...

y al Ministro de Relaciones Exteriores Hyseni y darles las gracias por compartir hoy con nosotros sus perspectivas sobre la región
Juegos Loola Loola Games Juegos Loola Juegos Mafa Zoxy Club
Jeannette, ¡muchas gracias por compartir tus experiencias con nosotros, y te deseamos toda la suerte del mundo!

Steven Jonhs said...

Thank you for sharing with me a few of your ideas regarding the possibility of alleviating our current unemployment troubles by instituting a shortened workweek.
gry elsa gry mafa jogos3 jogos da mafa jogos do minions
Danke, dafür dass Ihr jeden Tag mit uns die Hl. Messe gefeiert habt, für all die Reparaturen im ganzen Haus, für Euere Bereitschaft
jogos do papa louie juegos de mafa juegos de papa louie juegos fynsy juegos gogy

Anonymous said...

New experience for each of your emotions. Thrilling, vibrations of love, adventure adventurous or want to destroy all ... are transformed into this game:
Doraemon Games

Steven Jonhs said...

Ich würde mich freuen, wenn Sie uns auch künftig begleiten und danke Ihnen für Ihre Unterstützung und das in uns gesetzte Vertrauen
Friv 12 Games
Friv 2017 Games
Friv 5 Games
Friv 50000 games

Die einmaligen reperti, die bilden können, sind eine gültige Hilfe im chronologischen Wiederaufbau angesiedelt die Keramikreperti, die in großer Quantität in Nähe Trigona wiedergefunden wurden
Jeux De Yepi 2017
Juegos De Friv 2017
Juegos De Friv 2
Kizi 2017 Games
Yoop games

Anonymous said...

To flee war, to protect the lives of themselves and their families, and must live with the rhythm of society, sometimes makes people feel comfortable smell.
Mario Games , Friv , Doraemon Games , Kizi

Unknown said...

Busy life circumstances than the current world history. Must try to earn money to support themselves, their families and pay for living.
Pou Games , Dora games , K7x
Toon Games , Y8 , K6x

Unknown said...

This topic is interesting. This information is very useful to me. I hope there will be many articles or like this article. Thank you for sharing
Speaking of football games can not fail to mention head soccer . head soccer is a great game that every player knows games. Not only that Big Head Soccer or Big Head Football games also are a lot of lovers. Please entertainment with Big Head Soccer Big Head Football offline
Tiny Tanks other Tiny Planes are appealing for your child. In Tiny Planes you can play Run 3 Unblocked. Milky quite interesting if you explore all Run 3 Unblocked . The same play with Car Racing Games , Donkey Kong Unblocked and are also Super Mario Unblocked offline

Unknown said...

Very good write-up. I certainly love this site. Keep writing!
this blog is really helpful. i found very interesting things here.
- minecraft games
- happy wheels
- happy wheels
- tetris
- brain games
- puzzle games
- agario hi
- abcya
- fnaf 4

Unknown said...

Merci au groupe scout de la Molière pour la mise à disposition du matériel et merci à Philippe Mooser (président du groupe) pour le partage de ses connaissances durant cette journée.
Je vous remercie, au nom également des autres membres du Conseil de fondation
Merci pour les deux pièces reçues la semaine dernière, et en particulier pour celle avec les contre-dépouilles.
C'est notre façon de vous remercier de partager votre connexion !

Unknown said...

This topic is interesting. This information is very useful to me. I hope there will be many articles or like this article. Thank you for sharing
head soccer unblocked is the main game in our website. To head soccer soccer heads will be played the famous game about Big Head Soccer . Big Head Football or big head basketball games as well as our favorite

The Head Soccer Big Head Soccer synthetic Big Head Football games famous. on head soccer you could be playing head soccer unblocked , big head basketball or Big Head Soccer Head Soccer Big Head Soccer Big Head Football big head basketball big head basketball are games is our top. Rejoice with Head Soccer Big Head Soccer Big Head Football Big Head Football big head basketball offline

Tiny Tanks is a popular game that all of you would like. In which you can play Tiny Planes, Run 3 Unblocked Run 4 Unblocked Hacked unblocked Games. Or you can go to play Tiny Planes Tiny Planes Beta
Run 3 Unblocked
Run 4 Unblocked
Run Unblocked
Car Racing Games
Super Mario Unblocked.
Donkey Kong Unblocked.

Unknown said...

Donkey Kong Unblocked. is a revival of the Game Boy Donkey Kong.The goal is to help Mario rescue the Princess. . In this flash game remake of the original Super Mario, you can play as either Mario or Luigi. Speed around tight turns to cross the finish line in first place in the cool racing games from Car Racing Games

Mircea said...

Ofcourse,China matters ,thanks for the article.We all are interested in the China politics.In the meantime just review some websites bellow:
Unblocked games | Mario games |Aarp games |Kizi games |Arcade games | 2 player games | y8 games |Super Mario games | free tv

Unknown said...

Wow!..Amazing.. I have no words to describe it
Cookie Clicker
Cookie Clicker play
Cookie Clicker game
Cookie Clicker online

Coco Love said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

Social networking can help me better relationships. I also use it to trade in a few items. It seems everything is very good.
baixar facebook l baixar whatsapp l slitherio l run 2 l happy wheels l piano tiles 2

AKPuran Gaming said...

Ich werde sicherstellen, es zu bookmarken und kommen zurück, um Ihre Informationen zu lesen, die für mich nützlich sind. Vielen Dank für die Post.
Juegos Friv 2019

sites said...

jugar juegos friv 1 gratis

sites said...

jugar juegos friv 1 gratis

mario lafez said...

fantastic website go and yes you can play best free friv games online on

mario lafez said...

bueno mucho .jugar mejor juegos friv gratis en línea en

mario lafez said...

site ou vous pouvez trouver tout les offres d'emploi et alwadifa sur wadifa ,alwadifa , wadifati

Anonymous said...

The only bad thing is u can't rotate the piece to the way u want it to fit in some spots but other then that it's fun and makes u think before u pickup the piece so that being said I do love playing candyland every morning at 4am at y8 online game

Anonymous said...

Your blogs further more each else volume is so entertaining further serviceable It appoints me befall retreat encore. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates

friv 5 | friv5 | | - friv 5 games - friv5 online - juegos friv 5

Gin san said...

Wonderful post and Thank you for sharing. Do you want play games online? Pretty cool game just wish the special challenge was as easy to defeat as the actual game. Still trying to figure out the game, but until then, having fun. Try other Friv 10: The Best Friv 10 Online Games! [Jogos | Juegos] for all ages on site or the hot unblocked game at !

Unknown said...

Gracias por compartir su pasión por el mejoramiento de Jogos Friv Friv 2019 Friv Games las vidas de los niños en el Estado de Friv Jeux De Fille Jogos Friv Gracias por vuestras reacciones a Jogos Friv Juegos Friv Juegos Kizi Juegos Kizi las transmisiones que os han hecho.

Anonymous said...

Much obliged for setting aside an ideal opportunity to examine this, I feel firmly about it and love adapting more on this point. On the off chance that conceivable, as you pick up mastery, would you mind overhauling your website with more data? It is greatly useful for me.
15 Status về tình bạn giúp bạn "sống ảo" trên Facebooks

Ielts và phương pháp luyện cho từng kỹ năng

Từ vựng tiếng anh chuyên ngành

10 kinh nghiệm luyện thi toeic chắc chắn đạt điểm cao

Làm sao để nghe hiểu tiếng Anh nhanh nhất

Anonymous said...

In this article understand the most important thing, the item will give you a keyword rich link a great useful website page: