There has been a concerted campaign to depict the South China Sea as an indispensable artery for commercial shipping and, therefore, a justifiable object of US attention and meddling.
This flagship of this effort is invoking the “$5 trillion dollars”
worth of goods that pass through the SCS each year.
Reuters, in particular, is addicted to this formula.
Here’s seven Reuters
news stories within the last month containing the $5 trillion figure:
What interests me
is that these seven articles reflect the work of six reporters and seven
editors (seven to six! Glad to see Reuters has a handle on the key ratios!) in
five bureaus and they all include the same stock phrase. How’s that work? Does headquarters issue a ukaz that all
articles about the South China Sea must include the magic $5 trillion
phrase? Does the copyediting program
flag every reference to the South China Sea omitting the figure? Or did the reportorial hive mind linking
Beijing, Manila, Hanoi, Hong Kong, and Sydney spontaneously and unanimously decided
that “$5 trillion” is an indispensable accessory for South China Sea reporting?
I guess it’s
understandable. A more accurate
characterization of the South China Sea as “a useful but not indispensable
waterway for world shipping whose commercial importance, when properly
exaggerated, provides a pretext for the United States to meddle in Southeast
Asian affairs at the PRC’s expense” is excessively verbose and fails to convey
a sense of urgency.
The kicker, of course, is that the lion's share of the $5 trillion is China trade, and most of the balance passes through the South China Sea by choice and not by necessity.
In other words, the only major power with a vital strategic interest in Freedom of Navigation in the South China Sea is the People’s Republic of China. And the powers actually interested in impeding Freedom of Navigation down there are...pretty much everybody else, led by the United States.
Obviously, words fail me.
The kicker, of course, is that the lion's share of the $5 trillion is China trade, and most of the balance passes through the South China Sea by choice and not by necessity.
In other words, the only major power with a vital strategic interest in Freedom of Navigation in the South China Sea is the People’s Republic of China. And the powers actually interested in impeding Freedom of Navigation down there are...pretty much everybody else, led by the United States.
Obviously, words fail me.
Instead, let’s look
at a map.
Here’s the map not
to look at. The oft-reproduced and
abused US Department of Energy deranged tentacled monster hydrocarbon liver fluke writhing in the South China Sea map:
Instead, let’s look
at Marine
Traffic, a most interesting website which offers dynamic real time ship
information and some useful historical data free of charge, and provides an idea of the actual shipping patterns in the region.
If you select the
“density map” option and zoom in, you get this view of the busiest shipping
routes (green lines) and busiest ports (red blobs) in and around the South
China Sea:
Note that marine
traffic in the South China Sea does a few things. First of all, much of it goes,
unsurprisingly, to the Peoples Republic of China and Hong Kong. Second, except when friendship-building volleyball games in the middle of the SCS are on the agenda, Vietnam, Indonesia, Taiwan, and the
Philippines are largely served by coast-hugging routes outside the PRC’s
dreaded Nine-Dash-Line.
Third, the rest of
the traffic that transits the SCS pretty much on a straight line is headed for
Japan and South Korea. This would seem
to support the perception that Japan and South Korea, our precious allies, need
protection against threats to their supply of hydrocarbon-based joy juice,
their economies, indeed their national security and ways of life emanating from
the overbearing PRC presence on the South China Sea lifeline.
Not quite.
The strategic insignificance
of the South China Sea to Japan and the Republic of Korea has been well known
since the 1990s, when "energy security" became an explicit
preoccupation of Japanese planners.
Here is an insightful passage from a book by
Euan Graham, Japan's Sea Lane Security: A
Matter of Life and Death?, published in 2005.
The cost to Japan of a 12-month closure of the South China Sea,
diverting oil tankers via the Lombok Strait and east of the Philippines, has
been estimated at $200 million. A
Japanese estimate puts the cost as basically the same to that imposed by a closure
of the Malacca Strait, requiring 15 additional tankers to be added to the
route, generating an extra $88 million in shipping costs. This is roughly corroborated by the reported
findings of a joint study conducted by the JDA and the Indonesian authorities
in the late 1980s, which put the number of extra tankers required to divert
around the South China Sea via Lombok and east of the Philippines at 18.
...The volume of oil shipped to Japan from the Middle East is evenly
split between Lombok and the Straits of Malacca...
Here’s a nice map
showing the Lombok route, also mentioning the only difference with Malacca—two
more days in sailing time over twenty days for the straight shot through the
South China Sea. Also note, as this
graphic does, that the biggest biggest crude carriers, 300,000 DWT and up, can only take the Lombok route.
What does two extra
days on the water mean? Per Graham,
...Based on an oil import bill of $35 billion in 1997, [a cost of $88
million for diverting through Lombok] accounts for 0.3% of the total.
To update these
figures, the oil/tanker market has gone pretty gonzo recently, as everyone is
aware. Crude prices have gone down,
while tanker rates are currently upupup as importers stampede buy cheap strategic reserves
and, on occasion, hold the tankers for temporary storage instead of releasing
them back into the wild. Most recent shipping
figure I could find was about $2.50/barrel from the Gulf to Japan.
Let's assume $30/barrel
crude plus $3/barrel shipping costs.
Japan imports about 2 billion barrels per year. That's $6 billion dollars. And we assume the Lombok route adds 10% or
$0.30/barrel to the shipping cost.
That's another $600 million dollars against $60 billion in total crude
costs. 1%. By a funny coincidence, $600 million is also
about 1% of the annual Japanese defense budget.
Japan's GDP: $4 trillion dollars.
So is Japan going
to light off World War III to keep the purportedly vital SCS SLOC open and save
1% on its oil bill?
Here's one fellow who
doesn't think so:
CSD [Collective Self Defense] will not allow minesweeping ops in
SCS/Malacca Strait as unlike Hormuz there are alternative routes.
That's a statement
that notorious appeaser, Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, made in the Diet, as
reported on Corey Wallace's Twitter feed.
Republic of Korea:
imports less than 1 billion barrels per annum.
Cost of the Lombok detour: maybe $270 million.
Bottom line,
everybody prefers to use Malacca/South China Sea to get from the Persian Gulf
to Japan and South Korea. It’s the
straightest, it’s the cheapest, there’s Singapore, and, in fact, shipowners looked
at the economics and decided to dial back the construction of “postMalaccamax
VLCCs” (Very Large Crude Carriers) so they’d always have the option of going
through the Malacca Strait and South China Sea.
But if that route
goes blooey, they can always go via Lombok and the Makassar Sea. Just a little bit more expensive.
So, the South China
Sea is not a critical sea lane for our primary North Asian allies Japan and the
Republic of Korea.
What about the threat
to the Antipodes? Core ally Australia? If the PRC shut down the South China Sea,
what would that do to Australian exports (other than to China, naturally)?
From Euan Graham’s
volume quoted above:
Iron ore and coke shipments from Australia account for most of the
cargo moved through the Lombok Strait...Lombok remains the principal route for
bulk carriers sailing from Western Australia to Japan.
They use Lombok already!
As to the South
China Sea factor, Sam Bateman, a retired Royal Australian Navy commodore who
now think-tanks in Singapore, debunked a dubious piece of
numerology by Bonnie Glaser:
Bonnie Glaser has recently claimed that approximately 60 per cent of
Australia’s seaborne trade passes through the South China Sea…
When measured by value, the figure of 60% of our seaborne trade
passing through the South China Sea is way off the mark. Based on the latest
data for Australia’s overseas trade, it mightn’t even be half that—and about
three-quarters of it would be trade to and from China. Thus the notion of a
threat to our seaborne trade from China is rather a non-sequitur.
Doing the math…25%
of 30%...that’s 7.5% of Australia’s total seaborne trade by value through the
South China Sea isn’t going to the PRC. Back
of the envelope, that’s A$40 billion, about half of which is back and forth
with Singapore, which could be end-arounded by entering the Malacca Strait from
the west and avoiding the South China Sea completely. So maybe A$ 20 billion theoretically at risk in
the unlikely event that the PRC decided to close the SCS completely to Australian
shipping. By contrast, Australian two
way trade with the PRC: A$152 billion.
If you are
wondering why there is a “spirited debate” as to whether confronting the PRC,
the biggest customer for Australian ore and real estate, in the South China Sea
serves Australia’s national interest, I think you have your answer.
Euan Graham, now Director
of the Lowy Institute’s International Security Program, recently appeared on
Australian television to remark that "geography doesn't change". No kidding.
It's worth watching
his appearance and his careful parsing of the South China Sea issue.
Notice he does not
advance the canard that the South China Sea is a vital waterway for Australian
commerce under threat from the PRC. It’s
more about Australia doing its best to act as a willing, nay eager, ally of the
United States in Asia, or as Graham puts it paying “the alliance premium”. And that “international law” thing. And free movement of naval forces.
It should be clear
by now that the South China Sea as a commercial artery matters a heck of a lot
more to…China, unsurprisingly, than it does to Japan, South Korea, Australia,
and the United States.
Here’s the funny
thing. The South China Sea is becoming
less and less important to the PRC as well, as it constructs alternate networks
of ports, pipelines, and energy assets.
The idea that the
PRC will ever wriggle free of the maritime chokehold is anathema to the US Navy,
which has staked its reputation, claims to a central geostrategic role, and
budget demands on the idea that the US Navy’s threat to the PRC’s seaborne
energy imports is the decisive factor that will keep the Commies in their
place. America’s interest in d*cking
with the PRC in the South China Sea predates any Xi Jinping-related arrogance, expansionism,
and island-building and indeed predates the appearance of any PRC Navy worthy
of consideration. It can be traced to
the Office of Net Assessment’s 2004 report prepared via Booz, Hamilton for
Donald Rumsfeld, Energy Futures in Asia.
As I don’t think
that report has been declassified, interested readers can check out this 2010
paper from the US Naval War College titled, “Your
Pitiful Pipeline Plans Will Never Succeed, Silly Chinese! Learn the Will of the Mighty US Navy and Tremble!”
(actual title, China’s Oil Security Pipe
Dream, not so far off the mark).
Indeed, Middle
Eastern oil, oil that at the very least leaves the Middle East by ship, is
probably going to be a big deal in China for decades. But the PRC is trying to do something about
it in reckless disregard of the friendly and disinterested advice of the (Motto: Share and Be Nice!) USNWC.
Again, it helps to
look a map. The Belt and Road initiative
is creating a lot of new channels to move energy and goods in and out of the
PRC that don’t rely on the South China Sea.
While you’re at it,
find the Andaman Sea. It’s between Burma
and India, to the west of the South China Sea and Malacca Strait. The PRC has already built a terminal at Maday in
Burma’s Rakhine State and twinned oil and gas pipelines to Kunming in China to,
as The Hindu put it, “bypass the Malacca trap’.
Those little red
men, by the way? Burma Army
battalions. Security of the pipeline is
a big deal for the PRC, something that it is prepared to ensure even if it
means blackmailing the Burmese government with the threat of unrest in the
border areas, as Aung San Suu Kyi apparently already understands.
And for container
shipment, the PRC apparently plans to jog the highspeed railway it’s building
to Bangkok over to a new deep sea port down the coast from Maday in Burma at
Dawei (instead of pursuing the perennial Thai pipe dream of the Kra Canal
across the isthmus separating the Andaman Sea from the Gulf of Thailand).
Also check out
Gwadar. The PRC has made a commitment to
invest tens of billions in the Pakistani insurrectionary, logistical, and
geopolitical nightmare that is the Boondoggle in Balochistan with the prospect
of sending oil and gas over the Himalayas to give provide another option for avoiding
the South China Sea.
Pipelines are, of
course, more expensive to operate and vulnerable to attack by local insurgents and
more mysterious forces, as US strategists are suspiciously keen to point
out. Ports in third countries are liable
to meddling by pro-US governments, factions, and regional proxies. But the PRC is building ‘em. If the US can spend half a trillion dollars
on our national security, the PRC is also willing to gamble a couple hundred
billion on its energy security in defense and capital budgets (and enrich deserving PRC contractors) and bear the added
operating expense of moving oil & gas from A to B not through the Malacca Strait.
Which means, of
course, it’s time to hype that PRC threat to the Indian Ocean!
As these massive and
risky alternative expenditures by the PRC—and the complete absence of plausible
threats to Japan, South Korea, and Australia interests—indicate, the only
genuine role the South China Sea played as a strategic chokepoint worthy of US
interest is…against the PRC.
Bad news is, with
the PRC putting its energy eggs in a multiplicity of baskets, if it ever comes
to fighting the real war with China—a full-fledged campaign to strangle it by
cutting off its energy imports (like we did with Japan in the 1930s! Hey!
Useful historical analogy)—we’ll have to do it in a lot of places, like Burma,
the Indian Ocean, and Djibouti, as well as the South China Sea. A real world war!
Good news is, as
the PRC’s shipping options increase, the strategic importance of each
individual channel decreases…as does the desire of the PRC, Japan, ROK, or Australia to risk
regional peace for an increasingly irrelevant sideshow—and the local interests
of Vietnam and the Philippines--diminishes.
What I hope is that
the South China Sea, instead of serving as the flashpoint for World War III,
may well end up as a stage for imperial kabuki as the US & PRC bluster and
posture to demonstrate resolve to their neighbors and allies…and an opportunity
for political posturing, amped-up defense spending, and plenty of opportunities
for the hottest of media and think-tank hot takes.
That would keep
everybody happy.
53 comments:
Astoundingly accurate and legible - thankyou.
Excellent article. Very informative.
Very interesting article, analyzing marine traffic density data is a great idea,
but the spectrum of issues is too narrow, focusing mainly on energy supplies,
several missing issues that struck me while reading, e.g.
--- underestimation of the Singapore hub importance for the containerized shipments, no alternatives yet,
--- missing issue of the SCS grab by China on the inter TPP trade
--- not a word on the influence of the Chinese dominance over SCS on the inter ASEAN trade
--- the security and stability is not easily calculated in dollars but it makes a difference, not only just 2 - 3 days of sea freight, not blocked aggressive expansions is a source of instability that can make region instable,
as for marine transportation:
--- overestimated transportation capacity of the gas pipeline in Myanmar (oil pipeline not completed yet) and gwadar weight on the oil supplies,
--- overestimated potential of the energy supplies from Central Asia (natural gas from Turkmenistan matches the thesis, but Kazakh oil no, it's too expensive now, e.g. kashagan oil is a deal when prices on international market hit 80usd up/barrel
couple of other also but that for marine traffic
US raises the issue of freedom of navigation but also highlights obligations to protect the allies (Philippines) and Chinese try to grab the sea that other countries claim as their territory,
Why is the author so harsh on US while forgetting who is the aggressor these days?
btw China as the only country opposes legally binding South China Sea Code of Conduct which would help to stabilize the situation
Penjelasan Tentang Insomnia | Penjelasan Mengenai Chikungunya | Pengertian Dari Penyakit Impetigo | Obat Parotitis Atau Gondongan Terbaik | Obat Meniere Alami Tanpa Efek Samping | Obat Kista Ganglion Paling Mujarab Dan Aman | Obat Alami Psoriasis Paling Aman Dan Ampuh | Obat Paling Ampuh Untuk Mengobati Vitiligo | Obat Tradisional Rubella 100% Herbal Alami | Obat Penyakit Laringitis Paling Ampuh
Kenali Gejala-Gejala Insomnia | Ketahui Gejala Dari Penyakit Chikungunya | Gejala Yang Muncul Pada Penyakit Impetigo | Obat Herbal Parotitis (Mumps Atau Gondongan) | Obat Tradisional Meniere Paling Tepat | Cara Mengobati Kista Ganglion Secara Alami | Pengobatan Alami Psoriasis Herbal | Obat Herbal Vitiligo Tanpa Efek Samping | Obat Untuk Rubella Pada Anak Ampuh | Cara Ampuh Mengobati Penyakit Laringitis
Kenali Beberapa Penyebab Insomnia | Kenali Penyebab Dari Munculnya Chikungunya | Beberapa Penyebab Munculnya Impetigo | Obat Parotitis Pada Anak Paling Ampuh | Obat Meniere 100% Herbal Alami | Obat Herbal Kista Ganglion Tanpa Efek Samping | Obat Psoriasis Tanpa Efek Samping Dan Aman | Cara Mengatasi Vitiligo Secara Alami Dan Aman | Cara Ampuh Mengobati Rubella Atau Campak Jerman | Pengobatan Alami Laringitis Herbal
6 Tips Agar Terhindar Dari Insomnia | 4 Resep Ramuan Herbal Untuk Chikungunya | Komplikasi Yang Dapat Terjadi Pada Impetigo | Obat Parotitis (Mumps Atau Gondongan) Pada Dewasa | Cara Untuk Mengobati Meniere Dengan Aman | Pengobatan Kista Ganglion 100% Paling Ampuh | Cara Tepat Mengobati Psoriasis Secara Menyeluruh | Obat Vitiligo Yang 100% Aman Tanpa Efek Samping | Pengobatan Alternatif Rubella Paling Manjur | Obat Laringitis 100% Herbal Alami
8 Buah-Buahan Untuk Mengatasi Insomnia | 9 Tips Untuk Mencegah Chikungunya | 5 Tips Mengobati Impetigo Secara Menyeluruh | Cara Mengobati Parotitis Hingga Tuntas | Pengobatan Paling Ampuh Untuk Meniere | Obat Kista Ganglion Alami Herbal | Obat Psoriasis Berkualitas Tinggi | Obat Vitiligo Yang Alami Dan Ampuh | Obat Rubella Herbal Paling Ampuh | Obat Untuk Penyakit Laringitis Tradisional
Obat Untuk Menyembuhkan Insomnia | Obat Chikungunya Paling Banyak Dicari | Obat Impetigo 100% Herbal Alami | Obat Ampuh Untuk Mengobati Parotitis | Obat Untuk Penyakit Meniere Herbal | Obat Kista Ganglion Herbal Paling Terpercaya | Obat Untuk Penyakit Psoriasis Herbal | Obat Vitiligo Tradisional Ampuh | Obat Alami Rubella Paling Mujarab Dan Ampuh | Obat Laringitis Alami Herbal
Thank you Peter,
here is my Norwegian translation of this informative article:
https://midtifleisen.wordpress.com/2016/01/27/gode-nyheter-verden-du-kan-slutte-a-bekymre-deg-for-sorkinahavet/
Terje
Amazing Article :) Im extremely affected by your blog.I’m happy that you simply shared this useful info with us.I am quite sure I’ll learn many new stuff right here! SEM Expert in Lahore
Blogging is incredible and every blogger playing a great role to introduce new things in blogging. I always like to fly on different blogs and read the strategies of different blogger to understand the blogging in more depth. Being a bloggers I really appreciate your works and no doubt your blog is awesome.
Love from Asad Niazi
Nice Post keep updating like this,
Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge Latest Mobiles
Nice Posting Keep on update like this
Latest govt jobs
exam results 2017
10th result 2017
Nice Posting Keep on update like this
Grammarly review
Grammarly discount
Get your own personal numerology reading.
Begin the most interesting journey of your life and learn your true life purpose.
eToro is the ultimate forex broker for new and pro traders.
QUANTUM BINARY SIGNALS
Professional trading signals delivered to your mobile phone daily.
Start following our signals right now and make up to 270% per day.
Do you need free YouTube Views?
Did you know you can get them ON AUTOPILOT & ABSOLUTELY FREE by using Like 4 Like?
New Diet Taps into Pioneering Concept to Help Dieters Lose 23 Pounds within Only 21 Days!
I got here to this blog and it helped me to characteristic few new factors to my information. really, i am seeking to test new element anywhere I find. great written weblog and treasured statistics shared here.
Shipping from China to Amazon FBA
zapya for windows
zapya pc
zapya apk download
zapya free download
but we didn't come across options amongst the third party apps available that can transfer all files yet.
Service Center lg
Service Center Nokia
Jasa Kursus Service HP
Service Center Vivo
Service Center Acer
Service Center Apple
Service HP
Distributor Kuota
iklan baris
Apple
A Good information for People always help them and keep you visiting again and again for more information Delhi to bhiwandi transporters
Thank you for the info! By the way, can you suggest any good china freight forwarder company?
Great website and I look forward to seeing it improve over time.
agen Togel
daftar sbobet
prediksi Togel Hongkong HK 6d
prediksi Togel Hongkong HK 6d
prediksi Togel Hongkong HK 6d
gbwhatsapp
gbwhatsapp apk
gbwhatsapp download
gbwhatsapp for android
gbwhatsapp for ios
gbwhatsapp iphone
Today it seems as though the pressure has gotten to the developers of GBWhatsApp.
There are many shipping companies in China, but it is very difficult to find the freight forwarding company that suits you,Amazon fba freight forwarder
I examine your blog site presently share great information right below. Package Shipping Companies
Wow what a great blog, i really enjoyed reading this, good luck in your work. Shipping from China to Australia
Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would like to request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian
single status certificate in punjab
single status certificate in india
single status certificate in uttar pradesh
birth certificate in gurgaon
single status certificate in bihar
single status certificate in maharashtra
birth certificate in delhi
single status certificate in kerala
single status certificate in rajasthan
single status certificate
Can you work overtime? Buying a professional yet trusted and also caring babysitter inside Dubai on the last hour or so? Our expertly trained babysitting services care for everything in terms of children. babysitting services dubai
Packers and Movers Gurgaon Provide Reliable, Safe and Certified Service Provider list, Get Free ***Best Price Quotaition and Compare Charges. ???Hassle free Household Shifting Services, High Quality packing Material, Office Relocation, Car Transportaion, ###Local and Domestic Shifting Service @ Packers And Movers Gurgaon
Thanks for sharing such a relevant article with us. We all know about the demand of the international goods in the market but do you know what the force behind it? Logistic companies are the driving force that has made things possible. Now you can get any product in any corner of the world without any doubt. Import and export business are in the hunt of reliable freight forwarders who can serve their needs irrespective to the size of their order and have access to shipping from China to Australia. Certainly it won’t be wrong if I say that without proper logistic support it is hard for any business to set their customer base in the market.
Good blog post. Thanks for sharing the useful information. It was really amazing and very informative. Keep sharing No doubt it will be very useful for my future projects. Cheap Shipping from China
Shipping barrels are used mostly in the transportation of oils and oil products. These include also crude oil. In this case, plastic barrels as well as aluminum ones are used
Cardboard Boxes Service
Shipping oil in barrels is also convenient in that several barrels can be stacked in a container therefore increasing the capacity of a single ship, truck or train to carry more barrels.
Barrel Shipping Services
Get Packers and Movers Jaipur List of Top Reliable, 100% Affordable, Verified and Secured Service Provider. Get Free ###Packers and Movers Jaipur Price Quotation instantly and Save Cost and Time. Packers and Movers Jaipur ✔✔✔Reviews and Compare Charges for household Shifting, Home/Office Relocation, ***Car Transportation, Pet Relocation, Bike SHifting @ Packers And Movers Jaipur
LOCAL is an independent life-style concept store that combines a specialty cafe, men's barbershop and an exclusive sneaker & street wear consignment store best coffee shops in abu dhabi
What Companies Are In The Logistics & Transportation Field
The change is apparent. From the last decade, the logistic and transportation business has been facing major changes. From embracing digital solutions to online taxi booking applications to real-time delivery tracking to last-mile delivery, there is so much happening in the logistic and transportation world.
Thats a really cool article, everyone at Novateus loved reading this post.
Thanks for this great post, loved reading your post
SEO Agency in Pakistan
I really enjoyed reading your post Mongolia tourism Mongolia
Had the pleasure of shooting with Kevin Lawson for my new website. He is super talented and really took the time to capture my personality. The studio is fantastic, plenty of space, and has a nice comfortable vibe. Definitely will recommend him for professional headshots in west palm beach, as I plan on doing more work with him in the future building my brand.
Once A Beautiful Italian Face Turned Out To Be A Freakish Fright. See what Michaela Romanini did with her face
Artboulle is crafting luxurious cast iron fence which are perfect for your home
get your brick stain easily at your home with are services. Home painters are serving all over in canada
You can get a competitive edge, thrive in the digital world, and earn more qualified traffic with a strong, integrated strategy by top seo company of dallas
Powerful love spells that can make your crush fall in love with you.🌟 hurry up give us a call now or you will lose your love
Food Crowd brings the freshest food directly from farms to your plate, giving the UAE community access to the best quality products being the best Organic Grocery Delivery in UAE
Combined Pumps have been in the chemical injection and transfer pump business for more than 20 years. Operating Chemical injection pumps for well water in our manufacturing facility in the heart of Dyce Aberdeen we have been servicing the Oil & Gas
Post a Comment