Sunday, July 07, 2019

80 Years of Injustice: The Joint, Serial, and Ongoing Betrayal of Korea by the United States and Japan


[This is the script for the extended audio version my May 13, 2017 Asia Brief episode "Shame in San Francisco: America's Betrayal of Korea".]

A continuing frustration for US strategic planners is the deep mistrust and division between Japan and South Korea.

You’d think it would be: You hate Communists, we hate Communists.  You hate China, we hate China.  We’re both US allies!  We should hang out!

But it’s never like that, as US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson has found out as he tries to wrangle Japan and South Korea into line on North Korea policy.

The current friction point is furious sparring over the placement of a “comfort woman” statue in front of the Japanese consulate in Busan, South Korea.  It is there to confront and shame Japan over its use of 200,000 Korean women as sex slaves for the Japanese army throughout Asia during World War II.  

Japan decided to be angry instead of ashamed and withdrew its consul from Busan as a sign of its disapproval.

The rancor between Japan and South Korea is deep and has its roots in a century of injustice.   

Awkwardly for the United States, the key injustice is the US and Japan ganging up to screw Korea at the so-called San Francisco Peace Conference of 1951.

Why a “so-called” peace conference?

San Francisco was not a peace conference dealing out victor’s justice to Japan after World War II. 

Big Four Allies China and the Soviet Union weren’t invited.  It wasn’t a peace conference dealing out human justice for the victims of Japanese aggression in World War II.  China, as victim with 40 million dead, wasn’t there.  Neither was Korea.

No, the San Francisco conference was the announcement of the new Cold War order in Asia, in which Japan was rehabilitated as America’s indispensable partner against Communist expansion. 

World War II was officially in the rear view mirror, and Japan’s victims were called on to suck it up and let bygones be bygones.

The biggest ripoff of the San Francisco Treaty was to allow Japan to set aside indefinitely the issue of reparations for countries it had ravaged during the war.

As for Korea…well, nobody wanted to talk about Korea.  In fact, keeping Korea out of the San Francisco Conference and the Koreans in legal limbo was vital to the joint US-Japanese project.

Japan had annexed Korea to the empire in 1910.  Japanese rule over Korea did not go very well.  

Rule was often clumsy and brutal and it was resisted.  And when the horror of World War II descended, Korea was stripped of hundreds of thousands of its people to serve the Japanese war machine as soldiers and policemen, workers in its mines and factories, and sex slaves.  

Approximately half a million died.  

Because of the 1910 annexation, Koreans lived and died as full citizens of the Japanese empire.

But as the Japanese empire crumbled in the waning days of World War II, it appears Japan decided to abandon its dreams of empire and re-invent itself as a monoethnic nationalistic bastion, as Ataturk reinvented the core of the Ottoman empire as Turkey after the catastrophe of World War I.  That meant dumping Korea…and forgetting the Koreans.  

Literally the last act of the Japanese emperor before submitting to the US occupation in 1945 was to downgrade the citizenship of Koreans, both in Korea and in Japan, by stripping them of their right to vote.  

By 1951 over 600,000 Koreans, many of whom had resided there for decades, remained in Japan.  Now known as zainichi or “sojourners”, they were considered to be an unwelcome, unassimilable underclass riddled with criminals and Communists, that the US and Japanese authorities were eager to repatriate to Korea as soon as possible.

When it came time to negotiate a peace treaty and restore Japanese sovereignty, Japan was prepared  to fling aside its claim to rule Korea without a thought.  However, Japan and the US saw a danger that the zainichi might agitate for rights and residence and citizenship and compensation in Japan and mess up the nice neat settlement that was planned.

The inconvenience was removed by refusing to let the Republic of Korea participate in the conference and put the zainichi on the agenda.  As soon as the San Francisco Treaty was ratified and Japan regained its sovereignty, it passed a law stripping the Korean zainichi of their Japanese citizenship and turned them into stateless persons.  

And once the Koreans were stripped of their Japanese citizenship, they were not entitled to share in the benefits of Japanese citizens, such as the compensation the postwar Japanese government voted to Japanese war veterans…even though the Korean veterans had been full Japanese citizens during the war.  

Having denied the Koreans  Japanese citizenship to strip them of any current rights, the US and Japan colluded to use Koreans’ previous Japanese citizenship to strip them of their past rights.

According to the US and Japan, all those things that Japan had done to Koreans before and during World War II were legal, because Koreans were citizens of the Japanese empire and subject to Japanese law.  Just like Japanese citizens on the main islands, they were not entitled to compensation for their suffering and ill treatment during the war.

Koreans, in other words, were only Japanese citizens when it could hurt them and not when it could help them.

As to the legal standing of the Republic of Korea, Japan and the United States certainly didn’t regard it as the restored government of pre-1910 independent Korea.  It was simply a successor administration put in place by the United States, which had taken over land that Japan had legally annexed with extensive international recognition in 1910 but then formally renounced in 1951 per the terms of the peace treaty.

Obligation of Japan to the ROK: nothing.

Less than nothing, in fact.

As late as 1957, the Japanese government was still claiming that the South Korean government should compensate Japan for Japanese property lost after the war.  And when Japan and South Korea finally normalized relations, it was not on the basis of criminal liability and reparations; it was on the basis of mutual commercial restitution, tying up a few loose ends after Japan had legally walked away from Korea.

The negotiations took 15 years.  In 1965, the Park dictatorship concluded an agreement to normalize relations with Japan that many Koreans regarded as a sellout.  Japan promised $300 million in cash and $500 million in soft loans; and with the encouragement of the United States, the ROK endorsed the San Francisco Treaty as a “final settlement”.  The resultant demonstrations and rioting brought martial law to the streets of Seoul.

As far as Japan was concerned, that was the end of it.  It had no obligation either for 35 years of colonization or for its conduct during the war.

But for Korea it was just the beginning of decades of legal arguing and moral hectoring in an attempt to get Japan to acknowledge it had done wrong on the Korean peninsula.

A variety of arguments were put forth: that the 1910 annexation was illegal, because a key document lacked the Korean emperor’s official seal; that despite the 1965 agreement, individual Koreans still had the legal right to pursue compensation for abuses during colonial rule; and since the Dokdo islands had not been explicitly mentioned in the San Francisco Peace Treaty as Japanese territory, Japan should accept them as ROK territory.

In short, the entire historical record was trawled to discover any plausible legal grounds for compelling acknowledgment of culpability and compensation by Japan.

By review of thousands of pages of Korean government documents relating to negotiations over normalization with Japan, a new issue was discovered, one that had not in any way shaped the 1965 treaty negotiations: the comfort women.

It was an especially compelling issue because apparently only Korean and Chinese women were subjected to forced conscription as sex workers serving the Japanese military, not ethnic Japanese or Okinawans.  This gave the lie to to Japanese claim of equal treatment to Koreans as full Japanese citizens during the war and exposed the exploitative and colonial aspect of Japanese rule. 

The Japanese government dodged and weaved to try to minimize the public relations fallout of the wrenching testimony of Korean women who were taken from their homes, shipped overseas to military brothels, and forced to have sex with up to 50 Japanese soldiers a day.  No, smearing them as willing prostitutes was not the way out.  The Japanese government stammered out some apologies and mediated the establishment of a comfort women fund…funded by private contributions.

In other words, no acknowledgment of Japanese government responsibility, no admission of legal liability for acts during the period of Japanese rule, and no obligation to pay compensation.

When arch-nationalist Shinzo Abe came to power, Japan rejected the “victor’s justice” of World War II and changed the frame of Korean dialogue to Japan’s victimhood.  Instead of talking about the millions of Korean lives shattered by Japan’s imperial misdeeds, he obsessed with 13 Japanese abductees kidnapped by North Korea.  And by an act of the Japanese parliament, it was officially confirmed that Japan had never officially apologized for the treatment of the comfort women.

No surprise, then, that resentment still smolders at the heart of Japanese-Korean relations.

In the United States, jumping in bed with Japanese war criminals is seen as George Kennan’s masterstroke that kept America in the game in the Western Pacific.  In fact, the post World War II security structure in Asia is called the San Francisco System.

As one group of US diplomats put it:


The US has pretty much written the betrayal of Korea at San Francisco out of history.  Maybe that’s why it finds Korea-Japan hostility so baffling.

Let me try to help.

Instead of the beautiful friendship between the United States and Japan, think of San Francisco as the horrible end of a horrible marriage between Korea and Japan.

The husband, Japan, beat the wife, Korea, raped the daughters, sent the sons off to die on battlefields and in the mines. Then he abandoned the family, found a crooked court, and bribed the judge.  He got an ironclad divorce and dodged alimony.  And then the husband married the crooked judge—the United States—and started a new life of riches and honor.  And then came back to tell the ex-wife she’s not doing enough to make the relationship work.

If Koreans don’t find that kind of relationship beautiful, maybe we can…forgive them.

31 comments:

Ray Limantra said...

Indobetplay adalah salah satu agen resmi di Indonesia yang menyediakan jenis permainan casino serta taruhan bola secara online. Sebagai agen taruhan yang resmi, kami dapat membantu melayani anda dengan segala kemudahan yang tidak akan bisa kalian temukan melalui agen taruhan lainnya. Apa sajakah jenis kemudahan tersebut? Kami akan membahasnya disini.

Proses pendaftaran yang mudah. Kalian cukup mengisi formulir pendaftaran yang telah disediakan menggunakan data pribadi dengan benar.

Deposit ringan. Kami menyediakan permainan casino dan taruhan bola online hanya dengan modal sebesar Rp 50.000,-.

Alternatif deposit. Ini dia hal yang paling membedakan dengan agen lainnya. Kami masih menjadi agen resmi yang menyediakan berbagai alternatif deposit. Melalui Indobetplay, deposit dapat dilakukan melalui transfer antar bank (BCA, BNI, BRI, Mandiri, CIMB Niaga, & Danamon), aplikasi pembayaran (OVO, Dana, & LinkAja), dan PULSA (XL & Telkomsel).
Untuk pemain-pemain ataupun member yang aktif, kami telah mempersiapkan sejumlah bonus cashback yang berlaku dalam setiap permainan, yaitu:

Cashback sportsbook 5%
Cashback sabung ayam 10%
Cashback tembak ikan 10%
Cashback bola tangkas 10%

Ini adalah penjelasan singkat tentang kami, Indobetplay. Apabila anda masih memiliki pertanyaan yang ingin disampaikan, ataupun memiliki keinginan untuk bergabung dengan kami, dapat langsung mengunjungi situs-situs official Indobetplay dibawah ini.
dagbet
indobetplay
asla apk
maxparlay
wap.tbsbet
www.cool222.com
tbsbet
tbsbet wap
igkbet

Pissed off said...

Hello Peter,
If you are not going to publish on Newsbud anymore - is there any other way to get your analyses on a more regular basis?
Best Regards,
Ulf Warmlov
info@supertech.se

Paula Mastop Bentes said...


Do you need any kind of loan if yes my contract Mr Anthony who help me with a loan just few week's back , i just need to share this round the world to let people know that there are still good heated people in the world today . I really lost money to scammers online all because i was desperate for a loan . Until i saw a comment about him , contacting him his not a mistake but a dreams come through for me . Now I'm a happy man with my family . Contact him if you need any loan at :inforamzanloan@gmail.com

Sage 50 and QuickBooks Support said...

If you are new user to sage 50 accounting software and looking for the sage 50 technical support.If yes than you have come to right place as we provide efficient technical support service to customers who show complete faith in us. With our efficient and highly qualified team ,we never disappoint our customers.You can reach us at 1844-871-6289 at any hour of the day. You can also visit our website at https://www.accountingadvice.co/ for the complete knowledge of the sage products and services.


The Services we offered are following-

Sage Support Phone Number

Sage 50 Technical Support

Sage Technical Support Phone Number

Sage 100 support phone number

Sage 100 contractor support

Sage 50 live chat

Sage Support Number

Sage Customer Service Number

Sage Support Phone Number

Sage 50 and QuickBooks Support said...


If you are new user to sage 50 accounting software and looking for the sage 50 technical support.If yes than you have come to right place as we provide efficient technical support service to customers who show complete faith in us. With our efficient and highly qualified team ,we never disappoint our customers.You can reach us at 1800-961-4623 at any hour of the day. You can also visit our website at https://www.helplinenumber.support/ for the complete knowledge of the sage products and services.

The Services we offered are following-

Sage 50 2019 has stopped working

Sage 50 customer service number

Sage 50 Technical support number

Sage 100 Technical support phone number

Sage 200c Tech support phone number

Sage fixed assets support number

Sage 50 customer service number

Sage 50 support

Sage 300 Tech Support Number

Sage 50 and QuickBooks Support said...

If you are new user or exiting user of QuickBooks accounting software and looking for the QuickBooks technical support.If yes than you have come to right place as we provide efficient technical support service to customers who show complete faith in us. With our efficient and highly qualified team ,we never disappoint our customers.You can reach us at 1800-961-4623 at any hour of the day. You can also visit our website at https://www.quick.helplinenumber.support/ for the complete knowledge of the QuickBooks products and services.

The Services we offered are following-

QuickBooks Technical Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Technical Support Number
QuickBooks Tech Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Tech Support Number
QuickBooks Customer Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Customer Support Number
QuickBooks Desktop Support Number
QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Premier Support Number
QuickBooks Pro Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Payroll Support Number
QuickBooks Cloud Hosting Support Phone Number

ngoctrinh said...

Thanks for sharing, nice post! Post really provice useful information!

Hương Lâm chuyên cung cấp máy photocopy và dịch vụ cho thuê máy photocopy giá rẻ, uy tín TP.HCM với dòng máy photocopy toshiba và dòng máy photocopy ricoh uy tín, giá rẻ.

sean schinder said...

Hello everyone, really dreams do come through, i no longer have to apply for loans and worry over my bad credit scores, i got my blank ATM card after so many trails all thanks to Mr George, if you are thinking if its actually real the answer is YES. Mr George is very good at his job i applied for the card and got it shipped to my country 5 days later and i have been using the card for two months its totally untraceable, my life has transformed from paring an apartment in the slums to purchasing an executive condo with luxury furniture's and now my children can now attend quality schools, Mr George is an angel sent from God to the poor and needy. i am writing this with tears of joy as Mr George has removed my family from the life of want to the life of satisfaction.
you can contact him through this email: blankatm402@outlook.com
BEST WISHES

Unknown said...

By virtue of model execution, it effectively advances toward workplaces just as homes. Close by, the Roadrunner email bolster pulls the consideration of clients worldwide by giving remarkable assistance to them.
roadrunner email support
roadrunner tech support
roadrunner tech support phone number
roadrunner customer service number
roadrunner tech support usa
roadrunner tech support canada
roadrunner email help
roadrunner email support phone number

webspace said...

We are Webspace Inc. organization working as the Best Digital Marketing Company in USA and we give many services to our client that is website designing, website development, Search Engine Optimization, E-commerce web Designing, Software Development, Google Adword and Mobile Application.
Web Development company in Los Angeles
web design New York
web development New York
online marketing New York
ecommerce web development New York
internet marketing New York
SEO company New York
seo company USA
Web development company
Web development company California
Web development company Los angeles
Professional Web Design Services USA
Website Design Comapny
Web Design Company
webiste design services
Web Development Company in USA
Web Development Services in USA
website development company in usa
Ecommerce Website Development Company in USA
Ecommerce Website Development Services
custom ecommerce development
Ecommerce Website Development Company In Usa
CMS Web Design Services USACMS Website development company In Usa
Digital Marketing compnay in Usa
Online Marketing Services
Digital Marketing Company Usa
Seo Comapny In usa
Professional Software Development Company USA
software development company
custom software development company
custom software development In Usa
App Development Services USA
Mobile App development Company
Mobile Application Development Services

QuickBooks Support Phone Number said...

Brussels Airlines is the biggest airlines of Belgium based and headquartered at Brussels Airport. It has total 124 destination comprising domestic and international both. It mainly works in Europe, North America, Africa and Asia. As world visit has dependably remained the fantasy of each person. So to fulfill such dreams Brussels airlines has emerged as a way towards such dream. You can moreover approach Brussels Airlines reservations number 1833-5380-131 to book your flight tickets around the Europe, North America, Africa and Asia. Our agents on Brussels customer service will give you full assistance related to your flight booking.

aditya said...

Technology Mechanism supports countries to enhance climate technology development and transfer.

whizzherald
talesbuzz
janusgames
spy dialer
appvalley vip

Mason Olivia said...

Our Quickbooks all day, 24/7 support phone number is constantly avalable or dynamic for our significant clients or customers and help them in introduce, update, design, or oversee Quickbooks. So for arrangement of blunder codes or inconveniences just as for some other assistance identified with this best accounting software you can consider us whenever. For any kind of technical inquiry identified with the software, calling at QuickBooks Support Phone Number 1800-961-6588 will give you a speedy and simple approach to dispose of such issues.

QuickBooks Desktop Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number
QuickBooks POS Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number
QuickBooks Technical Support Phone Number
QuickBooks 2019 Support Phone Number

Packers And Movers Bangalore said...

Packers And Movers Bangalore Local Household Shifting Service, Get Free Best Price Quotes Local Packers and Movers in Bangalore List, Compare Charges, Save Money
And Time @ Packers And Movers Bangalore

shakib said...

assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs

shakib said...

assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs

shakib said...

assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs

shakib said...

assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs

shakib said...

assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs

shakib said...

assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs
assam jobs

Unknown said...

Awesome blog post, Thanks a ton for sharing such stuff.
https://medium.com/@PharmaceuticalDevelopmentGroup/everything-in-details-about-510-k-submission-f6a3424f739e
http://demandingbizservices.over-blog.com/2020/09/everything-in-details-about-510-k-submission.html
https://pharmdevgroup.com/facts-about-non-prescription-drugs/


Medical device consultant
Nonprescription drug facts
FDA expedited programs
Investigational new drug application
Post-marketing surveillance of drugs

Packers and Movers Ahmedabad said...

Thank you very much for writing such an interesting article on this topic. This has really made me think and I hope to read more.@ Packers and Movers Ahmedabad

Arabella Bella said...

Great post, I have perused this post here I got valuable data. This is an exceptionally helpful article for online audit perusers.
Frases Para Enamorarz,
Restaurants Near Me Open Now,
points near me now

Arabella Bella said...

I was checking persistently this online diary and I'm awed! important information uncommonly the last part I take care of such information a lot. I am energetic to find this post extraordinarily accommodating for me, as it contains part of... You have a conventional point here! I have bookmarked it and I am envisioning examining new articles.

Get Tech Expert
Daily Business Guide
Best Bussiness Circle
It Business mind
Top Online General
Pure Home Improvement
The General Info

Packers and Movers Ahmedabad said...

Packers and Movers Ahmedabad - We Provide ***Best Service Providers, Safe, Reliable, Affordable, Trusted ###Movers and Packers in Ahmedabad List, Household Shifting, Office Relocation: Choose Top Verified Packers and Movers Ahmedabad Compare ???Shifting Service Chrages, Price Quotation, Rate List Charts and Save Money and Time @ Packers and Movers Ahmedabad

Lucifer D said...

love it!!! Great job
HP Printer Support
thanks for giving that type of information. Really enjoyed this blog post. Really looking forward to reading more. Much obliged.
Top Recruitment Consultancy
It is in detail and well formatted that i enjoyed reading. which inturn helped me to get new information from your blog.
Contact Folks - All in One Helpline
This content creates a new hope and inspiration with in me.

Packers And Movers Delhi said...

Get Shifting/Relocation Quotation from ###Packers and Movers Delhi. Packers and Movers Delhi 100% Affordable and Reliable ***Household Shifting Services. Compare Transportation Charges and Save Time, Verified and Trusted Packers and Movers in Delhi, Cheap and Safe Local, Domestic House Shifting @ Packers And Movers Delhi

Packers And Movers Bangalore said...

Packers and Movers Bangalore as a Services providing company can make all the difference to your ###Home Relocation experience. Bangalore based Company which offers versatile solutions, Right team that easily reduce the stress associated with a ✔✔✔Household Shifting, ***Vehicle Transportation. we help things run smoothly and reduce breakages and offer you seamless, Affordable, Reliable Shifting Services, Compare Shifting Charges. @ Packers And Movers Bangalore

health said...


Nice.Interesting blog. You are posts are just amazing and very creative. Keep on share it. health magazine

sandy said...



شركة نقل عفش بالرياض رخيصة
شركة نقل عفش من الرياض الى جدة
شركة شحن عفش من السعودية الى الاردن
شركة شحن عفش من السعودية الى الامارات شركة شحن عفش من السعودية الى الامارات
شركة تنظيف بالاحساء

Indian Packers and Movers said...

Movers and Packers in Kandivali East
Movers and Packers in Kandivali West
Movers and Packers in Borivali East
Movers and Packers in Borivali West
Movers and Packers in Kharghar