Sunday, March 16, 2008

Tibetan Intifada?

Tibetan regions of the People’s Republic of China are experiencing a level of unrest that hasn’t been seen for twenty years.

Anti-China and/or pro-independence demonstrations have occurred far beyond Lhasa and the Tibet Autonomous Region. Thousands of monks have reportedly demonstrated at the Labrang Monastery, a major Yellow Hat temple in the Amdo Tibetan ethnic region, a.k.a. Gansu, not too far from Lanzhou.

This is a major public order crisis for the People’s Republic of China. The genie of Tibetan insurrection has to get put back in the bottle before dissidents get emboldened and the PRC’s rule over a quarter of its landmass starts to look less like occupation and more like counterinsurgency.

Holding on to political power is the one task the Chinese Communist Party is purpose built to accomplish. One of its critical arenas has been Tibet, which has endured invasion, occupation, the deaths of perhaps a million of its citizens and a brutal, fifty-year effort to fragment Tibet's political, ethnic, and cultural identity.
The CCP will attack Tibetan dissent with a grim combination of determination, desperation, and relish, and deploy every police, military, political, propaganda, informational, and diplomatic resource it possesses, even as the government struggles to maintain the smiley face China Rising facade for the Olympics and the international community.

The question that is roiling the Chinese government and, perhaps, the Dalai Lama’s government in exile in Dharmsala, is whether this represents a change in tactics, a new upsurge in militancy, and/or a challenge to the leadership of the Dalai Lama in Tibetan affairs.

Early reports on the violence trotted out the “ethnic powder keg” line, linking the disturbances to the Chinese beating a couple of monks in Lhasa, then reaping the whirlwind of outrage.

However, in an otherwise favorable posting on Students for a Free Tibet (hereinafter SFT), I was interested to read a criticism of Barack Obama’s statement of support for the Tibetans because

Senator Obama misses the significance of March 10, 1959; in addition to being when His Holiness the Dalai Lama fled into exile, it was when Tibetans across Tibet rose up against the Chinese occupation of their country. So while we appreciate Senator Obama’s support for Tibetan autonomy, we would be much happier if he recognized and supported what Tibetans are literally dying for in the streets: independence.

I have to admit that I wasn’t aware that March 10 is officially Tibetan National Uprising Day, usually commemorated by remarks by the Dalai Lama and demonstrations protesting the Chinese occupation.

And this year March 10 served as the occasion for activism inside Tibet as well.

As a European traveller’s account linked by SFT makes clear, the unrest in Lhasa was triggered by a demonstration, silent protest, or whatever you want to call it in Lhasa’s main square on March 10:

The day seems to be silent and peacefull, even boring. Until 6 o´clock. then 100s of Tibetans gather together on the Bakhor Square. They form a strong, silent, peacefull circle around the police who keep the middle of the square open. Soon they call for backup. Undercoveragents, not so difficult to recognize film the whole happening. Especially the faces. This is one method to create fear. Suddenly there is panic. 6 or 7 monks are arrested and driven away.

So obviously something was planned.

Which brings us to the imposingly named Tibetan People’s Uprising Movement.

In January it issued a fire-eating manifesto that stated in part:

The Tibetan People’s Uprising Movement is a global movement of Tibetans inside and outside of Tibet taking control of our political destiny by engaging in direct action to end China’s illegal and brutal occupation of our country. Through unified and strategic campaigns we will seize the Olympic spotlight and shine it on China’s shameful repression inside Tibet, thereby denying China the international acceptance and approval it so fervently desires.[emph. added]

We call on Tibetans inside Tibet to continue to fight Chinese domination and we pledge our unwavering support for your continued courageous resistance. [emph. in original]
The explicit political platform for the time being is:

1. Cancel the 2008 Olympics in Beijing and never again consider China as a potential host country of the Olympic Games until Tibet is free. [emph. in original]

The signatories to this declaration are the Tibetan Youth Congress, Tibetan Women’s Association, Gu-Chu-Sum Movement of Tibet, National Democratic Party of Tibet, and Students for a Free Tibet, India.

As I understand them, these are legitimate NGOs with significant standing inside the emigre Tibetan movement. (I would welcome knowledgable comments as to whether I am misinterpreting or overstating the standing of the Tibetan People's Uprising Movement, hereinafter TPUM).

A February account of a training session indicates that some members of the Dharmsala establishment are supporting TPUM so this is more than a fringe group of hotheads:

Besides the heads of the five Organizations, the 3-day workshop was also deliberated by Mr. Karma Yeshi, Member, Tibetan Parliament in Exile and Editor in Chief, Voice of Tibet, Ven. Lobsang Jinpa, Editor, Sheja (Tibetan Newsletter), Mr. Tendor, Deputy Director, SFT Headquarters, New York and Mr. Lobsang Yeshi, Former Vice President, Tibetan Youth Congress. The training subjects include the Importance of Co-ordinated Movement, Contemporary Chinese Political Scenario, Strategy and Vision, Situation inside Tibet, Olympic politics, Media and Messaging, Non-Violent Direct Action and Fund-Raising Strategy.

I think one can also take it as a sign of the movement’s importance that their website, which is certainly blocked inside China, is apparently being disrupted at its source by the Chinese.

The links I’ve provided above get you to the archived pages, but I’ve been unable to access the home page, getting the “This page cannot be displayed” error message. If the Chinese really are hacking the TPUM site, or even just launching a denial-of-service attack, that will provide ample food for thought for people concerned about Chinese cyber warfare intentions.

James Fallows reports that inside China, main foreign media websites aren’t blocked, but any page with the words Tibet are.

SFT reports that all Youtube is blocked, a recognition of the utility of video in breaking down censorship (no keywords to catch) and the extensive use of Youtube by emigre Tibetans.

TPUM's key public March 10 action was to be a march to the Tibetan border from India, something that was quickly squelched by the Indian authorities with the arrest of 102 people.

One doesn't have to choose between the local powderkeg and outside agitator narratives to wonder if there was any coordination and planning between the demonstrators inside and outside Tibet.

The Dalai Lama himself, in this year’s March 10 message, explicitly supported the Beijing Olympics, which puts him at odds with TPUM:

I have, from the very beginning, supported the idea that China should be granted the opportunity to host the Olympic Games. Since such international sporting events, and especially the Olympics, uphold the principles of freedom of speech, freedom of expression, equality and friendship, China should proveherself a good host by providing these freedoms. Therefore, besides sending their athletes, the international community should remind the Chinese government of these issues. I have come to know that many parliaments, individuals and non-governmental organisations around the globe are undertaking a number of activities in view of the opportunity that exists for China to make a positive change. I admire their sincerity. I would like to state emphatically that it will be very important to observe the period following the conclusion of the Games. The Olympic Games no doubt will greatly impact the minds of the Chinese people. The world should, therefore, explore ways of investing their collective energies in producing a continuous positive change inside China even after the Olympics have come to an end.

The Dalai Lama is, as usual, right.

The possibility that the current Tibetan unrest will dim the luster of the Beijing Olympics is already making Chinese go nuts on the message boards (see Rebecca Mackinnon here), eliciting the extreme Chinese chauvinism and defensiveness that makes any kind of rapprochement with the Tibetan government in exile almost impossible.

Which brings us to the question, what is TPUM thinking?

Did they want to provoke a crackdown that would create a groundswell of Western support for boycotting the Beijing Olympics?

Certainly, if anti-Han activism in Tibet and abroad turns the Olympics into a humiliating diplomatic and public security ordeal, instead of a triumphant coming-out party, the Chinese are going to take out their frustrations on dissent in Tibet.

Assuming that TPUM has thought this thing through, the conclusion would be that they are consciously trying to elicit Chinese over-reaction, exacerbate the crackdown, and alienate more and more Tibetans from the idea of accommodation with the PRC.

In other words, think of Tibet as the new Gaza.

The occupying power games the political/diplomatic system to counter criticism, but relentlessly extends its military and economic reach inside the territory. The occupied turn to militancy. They attempt to create an atmosphere of intense bitterness and anger on the ground through direct action and by the creation of a new generation of militants in religious schools.

The objective is to marginalize moderate and co-optable forces, make a successful occupation impossible militarily, politically, and socially, and finally compel the oppressor to give up and withdraw.

An interesting idea, except it hasn’t worked in Gaza, even with sub rosa aid from Iran.

With the Tibet independence forces actively opposed by India and the United States and just about every other government I can think of, I wouldn’t think that such an approach would succeed in Tibet.

And it would also involve abandoning the moral high ground that the Dalai Lama has assiduously cultivated for fifty years, turning an esoteric religion and feckless ruling class into beacons of righteousness and hope.

A posting on SFT makes a tortured attempt to reconcile the looting of shops and attacks on Han Chinese in Lhasa with principles of non-violence. But there’s something about an overturned burning car that says “angry rioter” instead of “nonviolent martyr”, and I’m sure that the PRC will be able to come up with some atrocity photos of some beaten up, burned, and/or killed Han shopkeepers if they need to.

If world opinion starts to regard direct action in Tibet as a Buddhist intifada led by confrontational hotheads, with monasteries and nunneries filling the role of extremist madrassahs, then the international opinion that stands between China and the most brutal public security and occupation measures may crumble and leave the Tibetan independence movement worse off than it is now.
Photos from via Students for Free Tibet blog


Kevcham said...

Here in China the BBC and CNN are heavily censored today - most stories on Tibet are being blanked out - but some are getting through - especially speeches by President Wen blaming the Dalai Lama for the unrest. Sadly, the Chinese people are getting a very one-sided account of the situation in the Chinese language media. They are so misinformed that I can hardly blame them - however, I can blame them for not understanding that they are being brainwashed by their government.

Will said...

A Tibetan intifada with the 'Dalai Clique' would not play in the West. Westerners have too idealized of a perception of Buddhism, Buddhists, and the Dalai Lama. At the same time, China is becoming more and more our boogey-man. Look for the separatists to receive 'moral' support from the Western media and politicians for a long time before we ever begin making associations between Muslim fundamentalists and Buddhism.

Ankur Sinha said...

It doesnt matter if tibet was at all a part of china in the past or not. If you see the indian history you will figure out that at some point of time or other, the indian territory extended to pakistan and afganistan in the north and far to the south east asia. It would be stupid if today India says that a particular territory belongs to it since it has been a part of India in the past.

What matters is present, and at this point in time there is a tibetian unrest, wherein people are not willing to be a part of the commies. There is oppression and human rights violation. Let the world impose sanctions on china to allow the peace loving buddhists lead a free life.

It is an irony that an athiest communist nation is determining the religious and spiritual policies of Tibet.

Do not crush centuries old culture in the name of communist growth which certainly is going to be ephemeral.

Have a look:

I hope the commies atleast allow proper information to vent out of tibet.

Anonymous said...

The Tibetan Civil and Human Rights Campaign continues its struggle against racist vile Chinese imperialism and hegemonic militancy attempting to separate the Tibetan Government from its people, to separate the Tibetans from our land , culture , language , lives... the over a million Tibetans slaughtered in manners that the above photos demonstrate - their blood cries out for justice and for the political, human rights freedoms of our people - why will not China permit the press free access to Tibet ? what is there to hide from the world oh sweet Red Army ? we have felt what you seek to hide - more of your atrocities and your unmitigated horrors of occupation - Free Tibet from the blood thirsty hedonist Chinese who torture our young men through cruel , inhumane "reprogramming" , dump nuclear waste on the land , destroy thousands of our ancient schools ,strip the land of her forests , fill the land with money, alcohol addicted Hans Chinese who dominate the economy, and the local government, police, etc. and who support the vicious occupation as invaders and mock and denigrate us and our culture - Free Tibet so she may live in the light of liberty

Anonymous said...


rest of url not published above

Anonymous said...

The Taliban , Muslim fundamentalists who treated as a welcome guest Osama Bin Laden and who permitted the 9/11 attackers to practice their deadly arts among them, using many explosives blew up thousands of Buddhist statues and other artifacts throughout Afghanistan but particularly in the Bamiyan valley in which two giant Buddhas carved into the hillside nearly 2,000 years ago were pulverized , the Maoist Red Army has done the same form destruction of Tibetan Buddhist artifacts for fifty years , using many explosives to pulverize Buddhist schools otherwise known as monasteries and all other manner of Buddhist cultural artifacts for the same reason as the Muslim fundamentalists , because they say we worship them as superstitious people instead of the idols they want us to worship - that is, they carry around their portraits of and build statues to Mao and Hans Chinese Red Army soldiers as some kind of religious icon and idols which they expect us to respect and adore instead of anything Buddhist , just as the Muslims carry around their Arabic inscriptions of Muhammad's name which they worship and which they hang in their temples and expect all to bow down to . These Mao picture worshiping Hans Chinese with their Red Army who blow up Buddhist statues and ancient articles etc, and the Muslim Fundamentalists with their Taliban army who adore and assist Osama Bin Laden and who march around with their idol the Arabic inscriptions of Muhammad's name and blow up Buddhist statues and other ancient articles are the same- Hans Chinese/Red Army = Muslim Fundamentalists/Taliban-Osama Bin Laden's friend

pery said...

It's very interesting that India--a primary supporter and host of the Dalai Lama--is such an ardent champion of Tibet.

Yet this same India has many nations struggling for independence within its own borders.

The Indian regime and its military have brutally occupied these nations like Kashmir, Assam, and Khalistan for decades.

But the the "Free World" turns a blind eye to this occupation because the self-styled World's Largest Democracy of India is an ally of the West.

Just as Israel--where a real Intifada is happening--is given a free pass, so too is India.

That's Liberal Democracy and Freedom for you.

Khalistan Independence organizations

"The Rape of Kashmir: Parallels with the Israeli Occupation of Palestine"

Unknown said...

Also, Dr. Sultan and the sanctuary providers are and were able to look truth squarely in the face, without retreating to the comfortable fantasy of denial, and/or of repression of difficult thoughts and emotions. Salute.

download youtube

Hines said...

Very interesting article! Thanks so much for posting, it made me think a lot.
Free TV online

Tomas Meskauskas said...

Download youtube videos for free, use

Unknown said...

Really nice post, you got great blog and Thank you for sharing This excellently written content. Waiting for next one.

HP - Pavilion 15.6" Laptop - 4GB Memory - 500GB Hard Drive - White

HP - Pavilion 15.6"- 8GB Memory - 750GB Hard Drive - Natural Silver